GummiBear: Nice avatar, a little dark for my taste, but its quality is high. The border fits it well, and the image overall works looks pretty good. If your looking for ways to improve it, I might point out that there is a little area of white pixels on the lower right corner that stand out alot (you might consider matching them to the background). But I'm just nit picking.
4/5
Inferno: Fairly plain and unimaginative. Not much to it, just an old english "D" and black background. I'm not even a fan of the font, but I'm not trying to be mean

, Maybe a white border would help?
2/5
Image 1, I don't quite understand what you want us to rate about them, considering all thats been done is changing the file format... by making them a GIF, the color coding can't really handle the vibrant colors, so its very pixely, and there are many miscolored areas. I'm not a big fan, especially since its a downgrade from the origional, and it even has Paradigm's Watermark on the lower right corner...
1/5
Image 2, I'm going to have the say the same thing that I did for image 1, so whats different about them, I'm interested in hearing what you mightve done to them?
1/5
Image 3, a bit better, still not great though. The eye is incredibly noticable from the rest of the image, no shading at all. Its cute, but theres not much to it. And I still can't help but notice the watermark
2/5
By the way, I believe this thread is for rating avatars, I'm no mod or anything, but you mightve considered making a new thread asking what others think of the images, maybe tell them what you've done to the images so its not just another "OOOO-ooOOO, RATE MY PIXORS!!!" thread.
Trisa: As I've said before, the image is quite clean and buetiful. Its got a very light mood, which I like. Cute drawing, I'll rate it the same way I did last time.
5/5, Excellent Job!
Other Picture, Nice avatar, it doesn't look as well around the edges of the hair, but its still of high quality. I like the border, but the color doesn't fit the image as well, maybe something more "Out There" might fit it better? Like pink, the color of her hair? Nice anyway.
4/5
By the way, on a note to R. Smith, the new avatars much better!