Rate The Banner/Signature

xana_fae,
Quality of image is pretty good. The only problem that I notice with the image is that the text is really grainy. Sometimes it's hard to make out what it says. Also, the height is a bit above the maximum requirements. Other than that, it's a pretty interesting banner you got there. I give it a 8/10

RogersGirl,
Quality of image is OK. The person is very grainy and doesn't look very good at all. Although the background fits with the overall image, the quality of it overall is pretty bad. It's a good banner, if not for the poor quality. I give it a 7/10

Darkside,
Quality of image is good. Some of the text looks kind of odd (you can still see some white spots on it). Other than that, it's pretty cool overall. I give it a 8.5/10

GummiBear289,
Quality of image is very nice. I like the effect you applied to the image. It also matches very well with your avatar. There isn't any grainy artifacts that I notice at all. Overall, a very nice job. I give it a 9/10

Almasy,
Quality of image is very nice. I like how you use your skills to make some pretty interesting banners. Clarity is very good, and there isn't any grainy artifacts at all. Overall, it's very nice. I give it a 9/10

New banner. For those who don't know, they are from Alien 9.

Later,
Trisa

Trisa: Haven't seen the anime. but the image quality is good.....9/10

Yes.....another FMA sig. I wanted to have Al in there too (He had dots for eyes and was blushing...it added to the funniness) But Photobucket resized it because I can't save them in gif formats on my mom's computer. So I had to cut it down the Ed and Winry....What do you think?

The Full Metal Alchemist banner isn't all that bad. I think it is a pretty funny image as it stands now... The only real complaint I have about it would be its quality. It's quite grainy, and there is a lot of pixel miscoloration. If the image was cleaner, I think it would be nearly perfect. The text in the upper-right corner came out fine, I think...

The first image gets a 7/10, mostly because of the quality issues.

I've always liked the second gif image, too. It move a little too quickly for my taste, but that's really just a personal preference. That image gets a 9/10.

Overall, I give your signature a 8/10.

Interesting concept Almasy, coloring is good too 10/10.

Coop's stuffin' a turkey with well chicken, what else?

It's a little grainy I know, not much I could do about that.

Almasy: Hm...aren't you modest. But that's irrevelent. You've got quite the interesting signature, I must say. It's a bit odd, since that shade of blue doesn't exactly go with the grayscale. It kind of burns my eyes though. But it's clear, and I do like that. It's very nice, overall.

Opinion: 9.5/10

Overall: 9.5/10

R.Smith: That's cool. It's a bit grainy however, not quite as much though. It's a little dark though. But I like it nonetheless.

Opinion: 8/10

Overall: 8.76/10

Later days:
JA

Edit:

quote:

Originally posted by Alana Gabriel Juvenile Angel. I like your banner because it's Phantom of the Opera, and I like your quote. So I give you 10/10. I however would rather it be from the musical than the film. 9/10!

Nyaha, so would I. But I can't find a good picture of Michael Crawford as the Phantom. T_T ::whaaaa::

Juvenile Angel. I like your banner because it's Phantom of the Opera, and I like your quote. So I give you 10/10. I however would rather it be from the musical than the film. 9/10!

A nice banner. I love the text: the font is very unique and really suits you! It's also very legible; there aren't any problems reading it. The biggest problem with the image is that it is far too blurry; there is also some grain around the outlines of the figures, but the biggest problem is the blurrines. The image needs to be sharpened or something...then I think it'd be a very good image.

I rate the banner (and by extension, the entire signature) 7/10.

---
Oh, and as a response to Almasy's comments: I've toyed with removing the red of her tongue; I opted not to, ultimately, because it seemed a little too unnatural. As for matching the colors...well, that's the green which is used onstage, so I did not want to mess around with it too much. I did try and make the color a brighter green when I first toyed with the initial image, but it looked horribly unnatural. Thanks for the suggestions, though!

I like your banner. Very good quality pic. (unlike mine, I tried to fix it but it turned out worse!) I especially like the smoke in it. I also like the quote. I would love to see Wicked. I give your banner/signature a 10/10!

I like...but its more like Clock Work Orange with out the twiggies....oh god none of you know what the hell I'm talking about!!!

8.5/10

xana_fae: I love Fairies.

Rate: 10/10

V Rate this banner on this picture:

It's a bit big, wouldn't ya say? The picture of Kaga is pretty blurry and grainy.. 6/10

Almasy: Um...hate snakes, not fond of topless women. However, the style and quality of the picture is good.

Content: 5

Technique: 10

I'll give you 8/10.

That's a nice little sig you got there, Ozymandius Jones. Goes well with your avatar. 9/10

Umino- 10/10

Beautiful Cutie Honey pan, not too big, not so small you can't see what's going on. And I'm loving the pink tones.

Dork: 10 for you too. Roger + Angel. What be better then that?

Dingo: Defintitely way better than your previous avatar of the same character. It is clean and crisp, although I think you should put a border around it. I still like it, though! 9.5/10.

Dork: A very good quality avatar! The color is vibrant and there seems to be no artifacts. Again, I think this is an avatar that wouldn't be hurt by a border, but is also fine by itself. 10/10.

Ozymandius Jones: This is a very interesting one. It goes very well with your signature. I also enjoy what you did with the text. However, the border seems a little odd. Ah, well. 9/10.

[EDIT] HOLY CRAP! I posted in the wrong frickin' thread! Oh, my god... How could I be so stupid?

If there's any way, could someone put this in the Rate the Avatar thread? Or delete this one, if it's necessary.

Oh, lord... I feel so stupid...