Rate The Banner/Signature

Tickle Tickle 12-10-2004 04:11 PM
Beth- It's a tad too grainy, and a little big wouldn't you say? 6/10

Gummibear- I love that picture of the Sailor Senshi sleeping with Santa leaving a present! 10/10
Green_Bird 12-11-2004 02:54 PM
Big Money: 8/10
GummiBear289: 10/10
Beth: Umino's right....too big. it streches the screen....I'll give it a 7/10....

Christmas sig! Tis the season Tongue ....
Tickle Tickle 12-11-2004 05:36 PM
Aw, no Kiyone? It's a pretty good sig. Very cute! 9/10
Asirt 12-12-2004 01:28 AM
Super Umino's sig has already been reviewed. Smile

Green_Bird,
Quality of image is nice. I like the clarity, and the font is pretty neat as well. I do not notice any grain or artifacts here. Overall, there isn't much to say about the sig other than it's very nice. I give it a 9/10

BethMcBeth,
Quality of image is good. It's a bit grainy, and it's far too wide to meet forum requirements. Overall, I like the idea, but perhaps cut some of the image off and improve on the quality so that it'll look better. I give it a 7.5/10

GummiBear289,
Quality of image is very nice. It matches very well with your avatar. The clarity is pretty good, and the color contrast is nice as well. Overall, it's very well done. I give it a 9/10

evanASF27,
Quality of image is pretty good. I like the text used for your train image, and I do not notice any grain or artifacts at all. Overall, it's pretty nice. I give it a 9/10

New sig, to match the Christmas spirit. Big Grin

Later,
Trisa
Avenir 12-12-2004 02:25 AM
Trisa - 9 out of 10. A little blurry all around, but this is barely noticable. Very funny signature image to fit the holiday season. Smile
Almasy 12-12-2004 04:48 PM
The Fallen Phoenix: Your signature banner is very colorful, which I love, but it's pixilated. Though, perhaps that's intentional (or couldn't be helped)? Either way, the image itself is very intriguing—it looks like it might be from an old video game. The fact that the image of the phoenix coincides with your username is very nice! I wonder if that ominous dragon also corresponds to a PCF member...Wink [9/10]

Madrona: For some reason, the image of the bell in your signature image conjures up in me a feeling of sadness. However, upon observing the image itself, I'm then drawn to the text, which is very inspirational! I like it! Smile [8/10]

Super Umino: I can't remember if I've rated your banner yet, Umino, but I really love it so I think I'll rate it again, anyway! The multitude of characters is overwhelming (in a good way!) and intriguing! I'm sure many people have stopped to take a good look, as I have! Cute and fun! Big Grin [10/10]

Big Money: I really like your drawing! The style is very unique! It's also very colorful, which I'm a big fan of. Did you draw it in MS PAINT? If so, I say you did a great job! [8.5/10]

GAT-X105: Cool! I'm guessing that's from the end of one of the Metroid games! The quality is very nice, though the banner is very small. Maybe a small black border would help? Anyway, it's pretty good, and fits in with your text nicely! [7.5/10]

evanASF27: That image of the (toy?) train is cool! I'm not sure if you did it intentionally, but the colors of the train plus the winter setting are perfect for Christmas time (and I'm a big fan of holiday-themed banner images for the Holiday Season)! I also know that trains are something that you're very interested in, so it's nice to see that you've brought that to the forums! Very nice! Smile [9/10]

GummiBear289: Very cute banner image, Gummi! The colors are great, it's Christmas themed, and it matches your avatar nicely (it's cool how your avatar reveals a tiny bit more of the image in your signature)! The quality is nice, though it seems to be a tad blurry. Anyway, all-in-all a nice, solid, Holiday banner! [8/10]

BethMcBeth: That's a very nice panoramic picture of Dorothy looking out over Paradigm! The quality of the image itself is very nice, but the text is very harsh and pixilated. It might have also been nice to have some sort of border. My biggest complaint, though, is that your signature image is way too wide (very much so against the forum rules). The limit for width is 550 pixels, and your banner image is 800 pixels! You definitely need to shrink it down. [6.5/10]

Green_Bird: I love group pictures from various shows, and this Tenchi one gets bonus points for being Christmas oriented! The quality could be better, but the colors are still very nice and I'm glad to see you have a black border (which I'm a huge fan of)! Very nice! Smile [8.5/10]

Avenir: Ooh, cool, an animated signature image! I'm a fan of Final Fantasy, too, and I really like the subtle "blinking" of the letters; it reminds me of R.Smith's animated creations. Cool! Smile [8/10]
angelcakes 12-13-2004 05:27 PM
Almasy: It's a very nicely arranged signature, and it's very clear. It's a very nice picture. 9.5/10

Avenir: Very nice. The animation is quite smooth, it's fairly clear. 8/10

Trisa: KAWAII!! Big Grin Me likes...not only is it very 'in season' it's completely and utterly the cutest thing I've ever seen Big Grin 10/10

Umino- I don't think I've rated yours yet...I like the downward spiral effect the picture shows. 8/10

Green_Bird- Can anyone say adorable? I can ^__^ Being a fan of the Tenchi series I must give it a 9/10
evanASF27 12-13-2004 07:37 PM
quote:
Originally posted by Almasy
evanASF27: That image of the (toy?) train is cool! I'm not sure if you did it intentionally, but the colors of the train plus the winter setting are perfect for Christmas time (and I'm a big fan of holiday-themed banner images for the Holiday Season)! I also know that trains are something that you're very interested in, so it's nice to see that you've brought that to the forums! Very nice! Smile [9/10]

It ain't a toy silly Wink Tis a computer simulation Smile The engine and the two coaches (which actually are the color they are in the show) are models that are run in M$ Train Simulator Wink Thank you for the compliments though! Big Grin


Since I already did Almasy's...

angelcakes- A very nice picture...though the person in it is a bit blurred. It would be better if she wasn't blurred as much. But still, a solid 8/10
Christina Perry 12-14-2004 11:05 AM
Evan: That Paragidm City awards pic is so awsome.

Rate: 9.9/10

V Rate this signature I made.
evanASF27 12-14-2004 02:51 PM
quote:
Originally posted by RogersGirl
Evan: That Paragidm City awards pic is so awsome.

Rate: 9.9/10

V Rate this signature I made.

Uhh...that ISN'T an awards pic in my sig O_o...





oh yes...umm rate your sig. hmmm...
The one you have attached in your post isn't that great. The words really take away from the pic's greatness...6/10

The one you have currently though is another story. Very plain, but it isn't really boring in my opinion. A very clear pic with nice fonts and colors. Well done! 8/10
Tickle Tickle 12-14-2004 02:58 PM
I'm really digging it, very cute, and seems to fit with the holidays (that's the snowny background talking) 9/10
R.Jesse 12-14-2004 04:25 PM
7/10 umino
8/10 evan
Tickle Tickle 12-14-2004 04:35 PM
A grainy, really bad picture edit, Jesse I think it's about time you get Photoshop. 2/10
Darkside 12-15-2004 06:05 PM
Umino: 8/10 colorful and funny
MidnightLight 12-15-2004 10:15 PM
I like the fact that it's so random, and it is clear. 9/10
xana_fae 12-17-2004 12:25 AM
7/10

because it's fuzzy a bit....but it's really cool...
R.Jesse 12-19-2004 01:03 AM
xana: what is it? 8/10
The Baker St. Irregular 12-19-2004 02:07 AM
Trisa: That yellow cat thing freaks me out. But it's a very good quality picture, nonetheless! Has a nice holiday feel to it, too. 9/10.

Darkside: The picture is very cute, although the picture of the text under it looks a little funny. Ah, well. 8/10.

MidnightLight: It's a clean animation on a good loop. I think it's faster than it needs to be, though. The colored text under it adds a very nice touch, too. 9.5/10.
Tickle Tickle 12-19-2004 04:33 PM
What a cute Black Jack sig! Clear, and very amusing. 10/10
Buck Buck #1 12-19-2004 05:01 PM
Umino; one of best sigs here imo 10/10