Rate The Banner/Signature

Prons 10-12-2004 07:30 PM
quote:
Originally posted by Wienberg
Trisa:

First of all, the eye. This is probably one of the poorer in quality eyes. Certainly, this is to be expected as you blew the thing up to be seen, but even so, it's kinda blurry. (Also, may I suggest you make the eye a link to the Eye Game if you have the room in your sig).

Now, Not the Eye. It's a fairly good image. It is sharp and clear. But, the face and the arm have a big of miscolored or misplaced pixels, which also look too pixelly. The background suffers the same problem, but it seems to fit the background.

Sig (with eye):
7.5/10

(without eye):
9.2/10

Prons:

You know, I'm not going to rate your sig. The reason why is, my new rule of thumb is that I only rate people who's most recent post included a rating. Unfortunately, you did not do that. (You could have rated Cerpin Taxt's instead of Trisa's).


Well, the reason I did that is beucase I did not want to deprive Trisa of a rating, unless some one rated more then just mine.

As for your's wienberg: 9.6\10.
Dude Love 10-12-2004 07:47 PM
Okie Dokie Prons. That's cool you wanted to ensure that Trisa got a rating, but in the future might I suggest that you point out to the next person to rate, in this instance, Trisa, and also post a rating of the post before his.

Your rating:

It is sharp around the edges, but it is a bit pixelly. You really can see all the different Pixel "clusters" too well, which takes away from the "smoothness" of the image. Also, a border would be cool. Traditional Black is good, or may I recommend the color #404040 instead (that's the color of the table borders on Paradigm, which creates a cool effect).

8.2/10
Mike 10-12-2004 08:42 PM
Dun...dun...dun...dun...
dun...dun...dun...dun...

James Bond rules. It's very clear, no grain or any of that, and the contrast between the B&W and red is very good. Also, that looks like Brosnan, my personal favorite Bond.
9/10.

I made a new quickie for the playoffs.
Asirt 10-13-2004 10:30 AM
GAT-X105,
Since I already rated your current sig, I'll rate your attached sig. Quality of image is good. It's a bit grainy, and isn't very clear. The font is cool, but a bit hard to read. Perhaps use a different color? Other than that, it's pretty good. I give it a 8/10

Prons,
Quality of image is very good. It looks very clear, although clarity could be better. The font is a bit plain, but it's very clear. I don't see any other problems with it, so I give it a 8.5/10

I changed my sig once again; it's Miu and Yuuki from Piano. Smile

Later,
Trisa
Benjamin 10-13-2004 05:44 PM
Eh well I am not one for challenging your eyes, seeing as you mostly have no choice but to make them grainy for size... ^^; It wouldn't be fair or nice on my part, So I give you a 7/10, Because the quality is 'Eh' and the size is 'Eh'.

Now your other part to your sig *does itialian kiss* Mwaaa Perfect 11/10, yes 11/10, those are the right numbers.

Now for who rates me...
Please Rate my attached image
Then Rate my Current Signature

Compare and Contrast Things
Pro's And Cons
Prons 10-15-2004 05:23 PM
Bigduo Inferno: The one you've posted I give a 8\10, what is that and what is it from anyway?

Tell me what you think of these mothers.





Tickle Tickle 10-15-2004 05:26 PM
I like the Kira one, but the other mothers are cool too.

Kira- 9/10
Others- 8/10
Current- 9.5/10
Asirt 10-15-2004 05:36 PM
Seeing as I already rated Super Umino's sig, I'll go right to Pron's attached sigs:



Picture 1 - Quality of image is pretty good. It's a little grainy, and the clarity could be better. Other than that, it's pretty good, but the pics kind of look the same. I give it a 8/10


Picture 2 - Quality of image is pretty good. I like this one better, but again, it's a bit grainy, and the clarity could use some more work. Other than that, it's good; better than the first one. I give it a 8/10


Picture 3 - Quality of image is good. Personally, I don't like this very much because it looks very grainy unlike the other two. I also think that the color contrast could be a lot better. Other than that, it's OK, but could use some work. I give it a 7.5/10


Picture 4 - Quality of image is OK. This is most likely the picture that has the most grain. It's very hard to see the characters very well, so color contrast and clarity could be better. Other than that, the scenery looks cool. I give it a 7.5/10


Picture 5 - Quality of image is good. This one is better than the other 2, but the color contrast could be better. Clarity looks betters, in my opinion, and it's a nice image. Overall, I give it a 8/10

Later,
Trisa
Tickle Tickle 10-15-2004 07:27 PM
That's a really, cool eye picture @__@ 10/10

Next person, current sig and this one. 'Cause Sister Jill is sexi.

MidnightLight 10-15-2004 08:45 PM
Jill IS AWSESOME! Very Creepy *shivers*

Chaplin Honey kicks butt! Tongue *dances with her*

They both get 10/10
Benjamin 10-15-2004 09:32 PM
quote:
Originally posted by Prons
Bigduo Inferno: The one you've posted I give a 8\10, what is that and what is it from anyway?


Prons, Its Megagargomon XD From Digimon Season III!
Prons 10-16-2004 06:39 AM
Big Duo Inferno:

The top one is very nice, it is unique, interesting, colorful, and crisp detial, and it has axes.

The bottom one I am not very fond of, ih does not look really cool, and the text scroll angers me.

Top one: 8.4\10

Bottom one: 6\10
Benjamin 10-16-2004 03:15 PM
quote:
Originally posted by Prons
Big Duo Inferno:

The top one is very nice, it is unique, interesting, colorful, and crisp detial, and it has axes.

The bottom one I am not very fond of, ih does not look really cool, and the text scroll angers me.

Top one: 8.4\10

Bottom one: 6\10


You do realize that they are one and the same right?

Laughing But anyway I haven't had a chance to rate your Gundams, I thought you could make a cool gif out of them But you didn't so I guess that it would have to wait.

But I love them none the less 9.8/10 Because one of them is just a bit different on the bottom
Prons 10-16-2004 03:16 PM
quote:
Originally posted by TheBigDuoInferno
quote:
Originally posted by Prons
Big Duo Inferno:

The top one is very nice, it is unique, interesting, colorful, and crisp detial, and it has axes.

The bottom one I am not very fond of, ih does not look really cool, and the text scroll angers me.

Top one: 8.4\10

Bottom one: 6\10


You do realize that they are one and the same right?

Laughing But anyway I haven't had a chance to rate your Gundams, I thought you could make a cool gif out of them But you didn't so I guess that it would have to wait.

But I love them none the less 9.8/10 Because one of them is just a bit different on the bottom



The reason I didn't animate it is becuase 90 percent of the time Animated Gifs suck.

-Prons
Christina Perry 10-16-2004 06:10 PM
Prons: Gundam is so awsome.

10/10


V Rate my sigature, please. Next... Takeshi Kaga (again) Frown
Darkside 10-16-2004 06:27 PM
Prons: Thats a badass looking Zacku, is it from the new SEED series? 10/10

RogersGirls: Well the image is nice but who the hell is he? 8/10
Almasy 10-16-2004 07:20 PM
Darkside: That's a really funny pic! The quality and color is nice, too! 8/10!
Tickle Tickle 10-16-2004 07:29 PM
That's hot. Loves it. 10/10

Next person, rate this awesome sig Trisa made:

Ozymandius Jones 10-16-2004 08:59 PM
Shocked Shocked Shocked Shocked Shocked Shocked ! Ok...it's a bit freakish...the pics are good, though...9/10, although the - er - woman? Scares me...
MidnightLight 10-16-2004 09:05 PM
I'm in love with Vash (and Seto if noone noticed Big Grin ) and I love this sig and everything he stands for.
It has good clarity to me and I feel I can give it 9/10.