Rate The Banner/Signature

Tony Waynewrong 09-14-2004 04:35 PM
Dork, I really dig your Wicked signature.

9.8/10 (I would give it a 10/10, but I don't believe in perfection)
Dude Love 09-14-2004 05:00 PM
Tony: Your banner is really cool. It's nice seeing all those faces of Dorothy.

However, all the faces of Dorothy are grainy and overall lacking in the quality they could have. They're just severly lacking.

The text part of your sig is better, except the blue is grainy and also is basically a bunch of halos of different shades (it isn't smooth). But, if it were to be smooth, you'd have to sacrifice all the Dorothies and choose one.

Next, there's the image of Dorothy playing piano. While there is a slight jump, overall, it's smooth. And, quality is really good!

Finally, we have the text of your sig. General stuff, same old same old as with nearly every sig, except you've got a Sib's section rather than a best friends or fangirls list.

Overall: 8.5/10
Asirt 09-14-2004 05:12 PM
Tony,
Quality of both images are very good. I like the second image better only because Dorothy is playing the piano. Big Grin The other one is OK; I like how the images is like a slideshow, but text usually distracts from the sig. I give it a 8.5/10 overall.

Dork,
Quality of image is good. The two girls in the image look a bit grainy, but the green border effect and the text makes a nice touch to it. I give it a 8/10

Mistress-Samwise,
Quality of the images is very well done. The Alex Row sig is very nice, as is the Save Big O sig. I don't see any problems with it, and the clarity is very good. I give it a 9/10 overall.

M.S._Feather,
The first image quality is good, but a bit small. Then again, it might because it is a animated image. Your second one is very good; it's from the Big O manga. I kind of like your sig overall. I give it a 8/10

Here is a new one to grade:


Later,
Trisa
Mike 09-14-2004 06:02 PM
Trisa: The top eye one is cool. I'm going crazy trying to figure out what's reflected in it!
The quality is very good so 9/10.

As for the posted one: Although I have no idea what's going on, it looks like it was something funny. Again, the quality is really good and the background isn't too busy. 9/10.
Darkside 09-14-2004 06:41 PM
GAT: I already rated yours

Trisa: 9/10, what the hell? (your attached sig)
Tickle Tickle 09-14-2004 08:46 PM
I need to see that movie again. @___@

Is it out on DVD?

9/10
Seraphim 09-14-2004 09:12 PM
Umino - Hey, that's a pretty good signature. It would be nicer if it was straight up, though.

8.5/10
seraphjei 09-14-2004 11:19 PM
haha...a song...i like songs ummmmm 8.5/10
that is a song right a hymn...boy im stupidSweatdrop
Prons 09-15-2004 04:13 AM
Seraphjei: Long time no see, aye?

Any way, your signature is very beuatiful.

+ It is very well drawn, and is equally well colored.
+ It has Kenshin, and Vash, and Spike, very identifiable (Spelling) characters in the Anime Scene, and thus it gets familiarity points.
+ It has a caption that fits the image.

- The "Spray Painted" word behind the main caption is hard to read, and it does not fit in very well with the image, I also don't know what it says.

Overall: 9/10

About mine, thanks to Krang I have a lot of One Piece images, so now I AM TEH NAMI!one
R.Jesse 09-15-2004 11:06 AM
PRONS 8/10
JAYCZero 09-15-2004 02:44 PM
quote:
Originally posted by Prons
Seraphjei: Long time no see, aye?

Any way, your signature is very beuatiful.

+ It is very well drawn, and is equally well colored.
+ It has Kenshin, and Vash, and Spike, very identifiable (Spelling) characters in the Anime Scene, and thus it gets familiarity points.
+ It has a caption that fits the image.

- The "Spray Painted" word behind the main caption is hard to read, and it does not fit in very well with the image, I also don't know what it says.

Overall: 9/10

About mine, thanks to Krang I have a lot of One Piece images, so now I AM TEH NAMI!one


It's say's Seraphjei Lol. But anyway's I got's to give you Sigpic
the picture quality is clear , I don't know what Character
it is but it's nice though ,kind of looks like Pippy Longstocking Lol
just kiddin , but I give it a 8/10

Tony I like your Banner it's very well Organized ,with all of your
Fangirls and you got the 2 animated pics of Dorothy , the Quality
looks nice so I give it a 10/10

well um Trisa..I that sig pic looks alright , I got to be honest I'm not
going to lie , it looks out of detail the animated characters , I know
that's the humor sequence of an anime but it just doesn't fit
as a Sig pic , but it doesn't look bad ,But your Eye Sigpic and the
Clue of the Anime Eye game I like , so I give it a 8/10


GatX105 Awesome Sigpic , I like the Gundam Robot , it looks
so McFarlene and I like the Dark Environment of the Picture
I'll give it a 9/10

Seraphjei Cool Sigpic , the Duo Spike , Rerouni , and the Legendary
Outlaw Vash , it looks like a Trio 2 guns and a Sword stalked in it
and I love the quote from it "Seraphjei, I shall fight no more"
and I got's to say I like the Graffiti style of your name in that
Sigpic. You drew this ? you got Talent man ! Kudos
I give yours a Perfect 10/10

R.Jesse I like the Optic Laser of your Big Fau correct me if I got
the wrong megadeus lol , it's cool , but kind of too short and the
Qualitie's Picture looks Grainy but it seems good , I'll give it a 7/10

Darkside I love Beetlejuice that movie was Awesome , good picture
from the movie , I'll give it a 9/10

Super Umino It kind of looks like that Blonde from Sailor Moon
but the Banner seems alright with the Damsel in Distress type
of situation , I'll give it a 6/5

Seraphim judging by the picture and the Avatar I suppose that's
you , but the Quality of your sigpic has a little bit of a Blurr to
it but the Quality for a Webcam pic is Excellent though , if I would
take my picture in a webcam it would look Grainy and Dark I have
to admit.
but I give your Pic a 8/10
Asirt 09-15-2004 05:05 PM
R.Jesse,
Quality of sig is good. The animation is good as well. It's a bit small, but that's most likely because it's an animated sig. The text is general, nothing really special about it. Overall, very good sig. I give it a 8.5/10

JAYCZero,
Quality of image is good. Only thing wrong with it is that it's a bit grainy, but more importantly, it's a sharp image, and I'm guess it's from resizing it. Other than that, a good sig. I give it a 8/10

Prons,
Quality of image is very nice. I also like the text of the sig, although it's a bit sharp for the eyes on the text. Other than that, a very nice sig image. I give it a 9/10

seraphjei,
Quality of image is good. The handdrawn image looks very nice. The caption is nice as well, but it's a bit hard to read because of the font style. Other than that, a good sig. I give it a 8/10

Here is another sig to grade. As you can see, I'm trying to find the right sig for me. Smile


Later,
Trisa
Tickle Tickle 09-15-2004 05:15 PM
Nice, I don't know what it IS, but it's cool. 8/10

The next person, comment on my current sig and this one:

The one I can't stop thinking of..
Love Buddies: Redd, Saturn, Prons, DoD, Midnightlight, Wazpy
Chat Buddies: DoD, Piano, Xel, Saturn, Midnightlight
My Simple Life Buddy: Almasy
Sadako Loves Umino
Green_Bird 09-15-2004 05:52 PM
Umino: Curent: I agree with Seraphim it would look better if it was up right 8/10 | Post: I like it....9/10

Also could someone rate this....It's chibi Goku and Gojyo fighting, and Goku has this demon kid on his back..... My first really good animated gif. I wanted to like add Sanzo waking them with his fan, but I thought the full verson would have been too big and it wouldn't look right because of the speed it has to be at....So what do you think? Belive it or not....I got the pictures off the net....
Prons 09-15-2004 06:25 PM
Green_Bird:

+ It is very cute.
+Very well animated.

Decent Quality.

- I do not know who the characters are.
- Its a little small, so if you decide to use that one, I sugguest having it centered on your signature.

Overall: 8/10
Tickle Tickle 09-15-2004 06:25 PM
Green Bird- Nice animation, even though I don't really like Saiyuki. 8/10


Next person rate this sig, and my current one:

The next person, comment on my current sig and this one:

The one I can't stop thinking of..
Love Buddies: Redd, Saturn, Prons, DoD, Midnightlight, Wazpy
Chat Buddies: DoD, Piano, Xel, Saturn, Midnightlight
My Simple Life Buddy: Almasy
Sadako Loves Umino
Prons 09-15-2004 07:55 PM
Umino: As I said to you on AIM, I like the banner a lot, especially the Shonen Ai theme >Happy !

+ I find it funny.
+ Its gout Jonunichi (Spelling).
+ Its got a nice border.

- The text is a little bit plain.
Overall: 9/10
Darkside 09-15-2004 08:17 PM
Prons: I've never seen One Piece but looking at that Jolly Roger makes me crack up 10/10.

Rate both sigs if you will
Tickle Tickle 09-16-2004 11:47 AM
Darkside- Scariii Monkiiii!!! 8/10

Ok, my third and LAST Jonouchi X Honda siggie, please rate:


The one I can't stop thinking of..
Love Buddies: Redd, Saturn, Prons, DoD, Midnightlight, Wazpy
Chat Buddies: DoD, Piano, Xel, Saturn, Midnightlight
My Simple Life Buddy: Almasy
Sadako Loves Umino
Green_Bird 09-16-2004 06:07 PM
Umino: 9/10 that one's much better......

Okay I have found this really embarrassing picture of goku....and I just couldn't help myself....It's from this segment in reload....called Urasai. It was the link between Saiyuki Reload and pokemon advanced. So this segment was made for kids. But I just couldn't pass this up XD!

(Oh God...eather this is cosplay gone horably wrong or Ni got ahold of him Shocked ....I also came up with the quote....)