Rate The Banner/Signature

Green_Bird - Very nice sig! Nice border, etc. I'll agree with XNE on this and go with a 9/10.

That's a good banner. I really like it (I'm chaning mine soon. For right now my obssession is Legato instead of Brad). It's very blue and the quote truly expresses Sheshomaru.

Clarity: 8/10
Personality: 10/10

Opinion: 9/10
Overall: 9/10

quote:

Originally posted by Reki That's a good banner. I really like it (I'm chaning mine soon. For right now my obssession is Legato instead of Brad). It's very blue and the quote truly expresses Sheshomaru. Clarity: 8/10 Personality: 10/10 Opinion: 9/10 Overall: 9/10

Thanks. I like your banner too, but it would be better if it was centered.

As for the text below my banner...

Green for the money, gold for the honeys, baby!

quote:

Originally posted by Xineohp Nellaf Eht Metal Gear: A very exciting image in your signature, there. I must say, it's a very good one. Some of the details are striking, and there aren't any major clarity issues (other than the occasional grain, particularly around the red aura on the left transformer). The font for the text is appropriate, and the text effects are great; it's a pleasant departure from the text in other signatures, which generally differ only in the font. Not much to say about the text in your signature; it's pretty self-explanatory. Overall, this is a very good signature, supported by a very good image. I'll rate the signature 9/10.

hey thanks!

Well, I added some characters to the top and bottom. Good? Bad?

Look how cute!! Unfortunatly, it horribly clashes with the Final Fantasy darkness.

8.12/10

quote:

Originally posted by R.Smith Well, I added some characters to the top and bottom. Good? Bad?

I think the characters make it a little hectic, in my opinion.

Xineohp Nellaf Eht: Wicked awesome quote from our good professor there!

quote:

"Faithless is he that says farewell when the road darkens." --John Ronald Reuel Tolkien

Could always count on J.R.R.T. for giving us some really good stuff. Classic! Smashing! Brilliant! Bloody brilliant! 15/10.

Hip-hip-HUZZAH!

quote:

Originally posted by Mistress-Samwise Xineohp Nellaf Eht: Wicked awesome quote from our good professor there! quote: "Faithless is he that says farewell when the road darkens." --John Ronald Reuel Tolkien Could always count on J.R.R.T. for giving us some really good stuff. Classic! Smashing! Brilliant! Bloody brilliant! 15/10. Hip-hip-HUZZAH!

I certainly concur. Mr. Tolkien has so many quality quotes, it's always difficult to pick one of them (I'm quite partial to his quote on marriages and soul-mates, but it's too long to be in my signature at the present time).

Anyway, to rating banners and signatures:

Mistress-Samwise: All start with your first image and move on down. I like your first one; the size is fine, the black border is a nice touch, and I love the text! It's nice to see some different fonts, and the color works well (not too hard to read or anything of the sort). No problems with quality; I think the image could potentially be a little sharper, but it's fine as it is, too.

[Image Rating: 9.5/10]

Nothing really to say about the links, so I'll just move down to the other image (looks to me like a scan).

[N/A]

The quality, again, is pretty good. No real clarity problems, other than the text; I think it's a little difficult to read due to the size of the scan (maybe make it a little bigger so the text is easier to read?) Other than that, there's not much more to say...

[Image Rating: 8/10]

Overall, both images are very good , and the signature as a whole is fine.

[Overall Signature Rating: 9.2/10]

quote:

Originally posted by Xineohp Nellaf Eht [Overall Signature Rating: 9.2/10]

Huzzah! Thank you. You're totally awesome.

quote:

Originally posted by Mistress-Samwise Huzzah! Thank you. You're totally awesome.

Don't thank me, thank yourself. After all, you deserved it.

Heh, made some more changes, well, more like additions. Comments?

quote:

Originally posted by R.Smith Heh, made some more changes, well, more like additions. Comments?

I like the girls on the bottom, but I still think the characters make it too hectic.

Overall: 8.75/10

(The girls on the bottom were a great addition, but they might benefit from being centered)

I'v had this signature for a while now and I was wondering what everyone thought.

quote:

Originally posted by thebravest1 I'v had this signature for a while now and I was wondering what everyone thought.

I like the signature a lot. It's very nicely done, and conveys the badassedness I believe it was shooting for. And it goes well with your username.

Seraphim: I probably rated your banner a long time ago, but as I'm too lazy to check (and I'm starting to rate overall signatures now, anyway), I'll rate it (perhaps again?) anyway.

So we'll start with the banner. Quality is fairly good, though it could be a little more clear. At first glance you might not catch it, but upon closer inspection there does seem to be a lot of grain scattered throughout the image.

The quote is nice, as is the text effects and the text color. As with most, the font is kind of bland, but I've come to expect that from most banners. I do like the black shadow around the text...

[Image Rating: 9/10]

Nice little rhyme you have there; apparently you're still not giving up the Yellow Power fight.

[Text Rating: 7/10]

Overall, the signature is pretty good. Nothing outstanding, but it's not bad.

[Overall Signature Rating: 8/10]

quote:

Originally posted by Xineohp Nellaf Eht Nice little rhyme you have there; apparently you're still not giving up the Yellow Power fight.

"...that until the philosophy which holds one race superior and another inferior is finally and permanently discredited and abandoned;

That until there is no longer any first-class and second-class citizens of any nation; that until the color of a man's skin is of no more significance than the color of his eyes; that until the basic human rights are equally guaranteed to all, without regard to race -- until that day, the dreams of lasting peace and world citizenship and the rule of international morality will remain but a fleeting illusion, to be pursued but never attained." - His Imperial Majesty Haile Sellassie I of Ethiopia

Anyways, I quite like the rhyme. Green for the money, gold for the honeys, baby.

Thanks for the 9/10 on the image, though. It's my favorite Sig banner I've ever done.

The image is really good. Although I have no idea what the quote is trying to say, and I'm not a big fan of Inuyasha.

9/10.

quote:

Originally posted by GAT-X105 The image is really good. Although I have no idea what the quote is trying to say, and I'm not a big fan of Inuyasha. 9/10.

It's part of Neitzsche's Thus Spoke Zarathrustra. It's a pretty good book. It details (through examples and stories) how his "Superman" would operate in the world. It's slightly strange in some parts, and entirely far-fetched in others, but it provides some insight into a philosophy. The quote itself means basically what it says... that Chaos creates and everyone has it, so thus everyone has the ability to create.

And I love that moon behind him. ^_^

Money
Money
Money
Mooooooooney

Honey
Honey
Honey
Hooooooooney



Love it

9/10