Rate The Banner/Signature

R.Smith: Very clear picture. Besides, who doesn't like Batman? I like it ^_^ 9/10

I had to make this in Paint since I couldn't transfer it over to my other computer, but it turned out fairly good I think ^_^

Nice sig, weird pose, excellent expression on the guys. Little grain(if there is) noticable, but then again I dont nitpick. I fear I know what anime/manga that is from, but for now I'll stay unknowing and happy.
Final Verdict
8/10

Pretty clear image, although kinda bland. 8/10

Umino: I already did yours back in the day

BigOZ: I agree with Umino. It is kind of dull and plain. 6/10



I just put up a new one I made. It fits my avatar perfectly.

Umino: i like the way the colors work together, if there is any grain then its barely noticeable and its a Pan just resized. 9/10

R.Smith: I'm a huge Batman fan and that pic in your sig is from one of my favorite jlu episodes. 10/10

Cerpin: your sig is kinda plain, but i'll give you a 7/10 cuz i'm a generous guy.

Trisa: I love FMA and Episode 3 is a cool episode. very nice quality to the picture. 10/10

Nathjan - 8 out of 10

A very nice and colorful banner image, and I really like your font choice for the text. However, there are some minor grain spots, most noticeably to the latter right, and the text color blends in too much with the image and doesn't capture the attention of the eyes well. Overall, it is a great image.

Avenir: It's a very well drawn image. Just wish it wasn't so dark. I know it's from FF7: Advent Children so it keeps with the theme with your avatar. 8/10

Edit: Been playing too much FF8 recently. Thanks for pointing that out, Avenir. Duh.

BabyGhia: 8/10: very nice, excellent quality, have no idea where its from.

withthe Transformers movie is coming out in 2006, and Spielberg supposedly announcing a director in a week or two, people have speculated on who it is. One person suggested Mel Gibson and came up with this:

• Attachment: luckypassion.jpg

Darkside:
Its good to be bad. Oh so very good.
9/10 for the sheer badassium in your sig.
PS:I would see the Passion of the Prime

BigOZ - 8 out of 10

I really like the image; it does unique justice to the great "Cast in the Name of God Ye Not Guilty" phrase and it blends in with the forum background quite well. However, I feel the comma and period are unnecessary.

As for the text, I cannot comment on the link but I giggle at reading the first line; it is quite funny.

Avenir,
Quality of image is very good. I like the art a lot. There isn't any clarity issues either. Not much to say about this sig. Very nice, indeed. I give it a 9/10

BigOZ,
Quality of image (or should I say text?) is very good. The transperency is very well done, and there isn't any grain either. Nothing else to say about that. I give it a 8.5/10

Darkside,
Quality of image is good. There are some grain spots that I notice, but they are hard to look for. Other than that, the clarity is pretty good, and the quality is pretty high. I give it a 8.5/10

Your attached image looks good, also. There isn't any clarity problems, and the image is pretty funny. I give it a 8.5/10

BabyGhia,
Quality of image is good. The clarity is good, but there are some grain issues that are barely noticeable. Other than that, I like the text, and it's a very nice picture. I give it a 8.5/10

Later,
Trisa

Avenir, like Trisa said the quality of image is very good and the artwork is cool. i'll give it a 8/10

Trisa, very nice quality with little grain and pretty cool look to it. i'm assuming its from Sister Princess. 9/10

It's clear and pretty nice, but it kinda looks like you're coping Trisa's style of sigs. 8/10

for teh sheer hawtness of Cutie Honey, and since its a fairly good pic...
7/10.
Why just that? I deduct for pink in the signature.

nathjan: Quality of image is good. However, I have to agree with Umino: BE ORIGINAL

6/10

Nothing is every Orignal, Uminos Sig probably isn't orignal. i'm pretty sure alot of people have pans resized as they're sig and the same goes for band banners which Cerpin has in his sig. Same goes with Avenir too, R.Smith had a sig with something from Final Fantasy and look at Avenir current sig, it has something from Final Fantasy too. were all unorignal with our sig in one way or another. anyways back to rating the sigs.

quote:

Originally posted by nathjan Nothing is every Orignal, Uminos Sig probably isn't orignal.

Last time I checked, no one had a Cutie Honey pan on PCF for a sig. But I could be wrong. But I doubt it.

quote:

Originally posted by nathjan Nothing is every Orignal, Uminos Sig probably isn't orignal. i'm pretty sure alot of people have pans resized as they're sig and the same goes for band banners which Cerpin has in his sig. Same goes with Avenir too, R.Smith had a sig with something from Final Fantasy and look at Avenir current sig, it has something from Final Fantasy too. were all unorignal with our sig in one way or another. anyways back to rating the sigs.

Mine's cropped and edited from a picture taken by a friend of mine from the last Mars Volta concert we went to. Besides, about a month ago, you had a sig that had the same exact font and style of Trisa (it said <nathjan> in the same damn font), and he didn't seem to care too much for it. Now all you did was change the font, but kept the same idea. All I'm saying is be creative and original, that's all.

Now back to rating sigs.

All:
Be sure to check this post on my thoughts of original styles in images. If you want to talk more about originality, be sure to PM or IM rather than posting in this thread. Thanks.

Cerpin Taxt,
Quality of image is very good. The text looks cool, and there isn't any problems with clarity or any grainy artifacts at all. I like this Mars Volta banner a lot better than your previous one. I give it a 9/10

Umino,
Quality of image is very good. It's a nice pan, and there isn't any clarity issues at all. Overall, very nice. I give it a 9/10

nathjan,
Well, before you took out your sig, the quality of image was pretty good. The font looked a little grainy, though. Other than that, there aren't any problems with it. I give it a 8.5/10

Later,
Trisa

PS. Oh, and for those wondering, this sig is from Sister Princess. The name of this girl escapes me at the moment...

Trisa: 10/10. Clarity is beautiful, and it carries your trademark name as always.