| quote: |
Originally posted by GAT-X105
eh, I liked Episode II. And number III is probably going to be pretty good. But Phantom Menace blew monkey chunks. They should completely remake it to not suck and have ninjas secretly replace everybody's DVD of it. |
I love you. Platonically. Or at least I agree with you.
II had its faults. It's not LotR by any means in terms of scale and the acting is subpar, but that's because George Lucas directed it.
Let's face it, he's a sh**ty director. He's one hell of a writer (at least plotwise), and he's a creative genius, but that doesn't mean he can direct.
If III is as good as II I'll be satisfied. If III is as good as V I'll be astonished into cardiac arrest.
Problem is, special effects don't last long and that's what he focused on with Episode I. It's often blatantly obvious when a creature or vehicle is computer-generated. Sure, it had the first "digital actor"...but in twenty years, will people remember Jar Jar Binks at all? Nay, but Smeagol...that character had an impact; that's because people want substance, and Lucas forgot that.
The reason I love episode II is that it does have a solid story. Look past the crappy, "I wish I could wish away my feelings" dialogue and you encounter a truly moving tale about star-crossed lovers (especially given Anakin's fate). It evokes a powerful, dark mood and when Star Wars is dark...it is very dark (see Empire Strikes Back). They say the third one will be the darkest yet, and that's something to look forward to.
As for the title...I noticed the semblance to Revenge of the Jedi as well. The title, and the logo, make it feel like one of the classic three films. It's not a bad title by any means, and in fact it's perfect for Star Wars.
What was with the Episode II title though? Not only did it lack creativity and originality, but the clones never "attacked." Seems like they arbitrarily pulled the title out of nowhere without considering the content of the film. Am I wrong about this?
| quote: |
| Also, the way they show Anakin as turning "evil" is the lamest thing ever. So basically...if you kill marauding, animal like madmen who kidnap and torture members of your own family, you become evil? |
No, it's not evil. It's justice. But I do think it sows the seeds and in fact makes Anakin's transformation more sympathetic. He's obviously tormented by what he saw, and that can easily be transformed into hate. He did the right thing by taking revenge, but that scene properly conveys the inevitability of his fate due to circumstances almost beyond his control. I think it actually deepens his character.
The seeds of evil were sown well in "Episode II."