Rate The Avatar

quote:

Originally posted by Wienberg quote: Originally posted by Zola okay, guys, how did the final version come out? Pretty good Zola! Although, I'd prefer it if you zoomed slightly out so that the corners of your eyes are more visible. Other than that, it's A-OK!

Well, I had this dilemma...

If I showed more of the eye, you couldn't read the number. If you couldn't read the number, you couldn't look it up here.

So that was my compromise

C.R Foxhound: Well, since you asked, I'll gladly critique your avatar. Now then, let's get to work...

The picture itself isn't too bad...there isn't much grain (so it's fairly high quality), but...its hard to focus on. I think that's due to the lighting (which isn't too bad; it doesn't add or subtract anything from the avatar, in my opinion). Actually, now that I take a good look at it, there is a little grain (most noticably, around its face)...that might have to do with it. The color conflict (between wolf and background) also doesn't help any...

The background kind of fades away from the viewer; clearly it isn't meant to be the centerpiece of the avatar. It's a nice detail (the spires, I mean)...though at first glance they are very easy to miss (what with all the blending and fading).

Overall, it's a good avatar...it isn't anything spectacular, but it's solid. I'll rate it 8.5/10 (85/100).

Alright I read through the first few pages or so, and I'm supposed to rate the person's above me right? Forgive me, but I don't really have the patience to read 40 pages I'm SORRY! So I don't know who has arlready been rated before...If anyone wants their's rated just ask.


Anyway, I know mine is nothing special or flashy, but is it alright atleast?

I apologize for the misunderstanding, well Phoenix I'll rate yours then.

It appears to be high quality, nice and clear, (not blurry or squished or anything) so that's good. While I don't know the character, I've always been a sucker for cute anime girls. On a scale.. I'd give it about 9. GOOD JOB!!!

quote:

Originally posted by Xithos Alright I read through the first few pages or so, and I'm supposed to rate the person's above me right? Forgive me, but I don't really have the patience to read 40 pages I'm SORRY! So I don't know who has arlready been rated before...If anyone wants their's rated just ask. Anyway, I know mine is nothing special or flashy, but is it alright atleast?

You only need to rate the avatar of the poster immediately prior to you, so if you wanted to edit your post, you could rate The Fallen Phoenix's avatar.

Yours is unique, with I appreciate. It's not Big O related and I don't recognize the character or setting, so it doesn't speak to me particularly. I'd give it a solid 8 of 10, because I like to see someone going to a little effort to get a unique avatar.

Pygmalion

quote:

Originally posted by Pygmalion quote: Originally posted by Xithos Alright I read through the first few pages or so, and I'm supposed to rate the person's above me right? Forgive me, but I don't really have the patience to read 40 pages I'm SORRY! So I don't know who has arlready been rated before...If anyone wants their's rated just ask. Anyway, I know mine is nothing special or flashy, but is it alright atleast? You only need to rate the avatar of the poster immediately prior to you, so if you wanted to edit your post, you could rate The Fallen Phoenix's avatar. Yours is unique, with I appreciate. It's not Big O related and I don't recognize the character or setting, so it doesn't speak to me particularly. I'd give it a solid 8 of 10, because I like to see someone going to a little effort to get a unique avatar. Pygmalion

That would be Vicous from Cowboy Bebop.
FP: For the love of Mike please dont use that fancy text-script thing font when leaveing a review for a person, it is very difficult to read and therefore hard to understand what you are trying to say.

Wingnut: Ah, a Gundam! And a very good one, too...picture's clear, no problems with the quality...

The transparency is fine, and the outline of the mobile suit is perfect. Of course, you have the cut offs on the sides and around the bottom, but it can't be helped...

All in all, a very nice avatar! I'll rate it a 9.1/10 (91/100).

quote:

Originally posted by The Fallen Phoenix Manji: Personally, I don't think it's one of your best. Granted, it's definitely top-notch, but not as good as some of your other avatars.

Aie, I'll agree with that, the problem is the computer I'm using, its hard for me to use photoshop with any computer but my own, its just so much easier if I've got my computer

Wingnut: Its a nice avatar, and I must say it looks very good for a transperant one. Its of high quality and its well deserving 4/5

Pygmalion: This avatar does posses an average uploading quality, and normal detail, but its just not outstanding. The colors don't jump out, and while the scene is good, I don't recognize whats happening. I think it earns an average 3/5

Xithos Your avatar is good, but it could use a slight bit of retouching. It looks good, but the sword is incredibly hard to see and it just kinda clouds the rest of the image, its as if you were focusing on 2 things, when you should focus more on viscous' face. I'd give it a 3/5, but with a slight bit of tailoring it could easily earn a 4/5.

:EDIT:

Whoops Pheonix snuck a post in there on me

Pheonix: Your avatar has very good color (I miss Tucan Sam's color ). It looks pretty good, good quality, and the picture is focused well. The brightness of the hair can vouch for its coloring ability. The only slight thing is the lower face where the face color seems to leak out just a bit onto the background. I'd give an excellent 5/5 though, Good Job!

I made it by putting together (re-sizing of course) various pics using a digital photo editor. I like making custom pics and Neopets.com Userlookup backgrounds. I think I could do better if I had Paint Shop Pro or something like that, though. I just wanna know if you think I did a good job. ^__^

hmmm its actually pretty good

quote:

Originally posted by Kat I made it by putting together (re-sizing of course) various pics using a digital photo editor. I like making custom pics and Neopets.com Userlookup backgrounds. I think I could do better if I had Paint Shop Pro or something like that, though. I just wanna know if you think I did a good job. ^__^

This could probably go in the "Rate the Avatar" thread...but it doesn't really matter. I'll critique it anyway.

I think it's a nice avatar. The editing was done fairly well, I think...which program did you use (since you say you didn't use Paint Shop Pro, Photoshop, or any other equivalent...)?

I only just noticed that the border was actually composed of faces of Big O...I think that was a nice touch!

Admitedly, you did lose some quality in the pictures due to the resizing, but that is usually unavoidable...though it is fortunate that rather than appearing in the form of grain or other horrible things, the only real loss is detail...

As aforementioned, I think it's a nice avatar...one of the better custom ones I've seen. I'd rate it an 8.2/10 (82/100).

---
Edit: Rating Included!

I used ArcSoft PhotoStudio 2.0 for Windows. ^_^

OOH OOH
I have new one: See Below
It's the full version of the one you see in my current avatar.
It's too big to be an avatar, but since I drew it and it's part of my collection I figured I'd post it.

Rate without mercy....

• Attachment: ConrairBlink000.gif

8.5\10 I added a .5 sense its nice to see you made it yourself.

Mine is simple Amuro Rei, I like to think the expression repersents not only how I feel most of the day, but how I bet other people think I feel when they read my posts. My avatar on the seraphim mfl backup arena 0wnz0ars though.

Not sure how to rate Prons' avatar, as I don't recognize the character and don't know whether he's heavily freckled or whether this is poor dithering on the part of a paint program.

I submit my new avatar to an uncaring world. It's derived from one of my altered screen shots in the RETOUCHED IMAGES thread in Nightengale.

Pheonix: The STNJ would be proud Your avatar is very good, I like the effects. Its clear, and the picture of Robin is good. I'd give it a very high 4/5!

Phoenix: Well, I haven't seen Witch Hunter Robin, so I don't know how to compare it, but your avatar looks pretty good. I give it a 8.5/10. It's worthy of a 9, but I'm not too big on anime mugshots myself.

quote:

Originally posted by Volt Phoenix: Well, I haven't seen Witch Hunter Robin, so I don't know how to compare it, but your avatar looks pretty good. I give it a 8.5/10. It's worthy of a 9, but I'm not too big on anime mugshots myself.

Haven't seen Witch Hunter Robin? That's a shame...I think you're missing out, but that's my opinion...

As for comparison of my avatar with show quality...I actually faded the colors and made the background murky. It also has a sinking quality...I tried to keep the focus not only on Robin's face, but also on the mood of the avatar itself...It's certainly not meant to be taken as an upbeat image...

I also think it's a nice effect, but that's my own opinion.

Now, to rate your avatar...it is a good gif. The animation is flawless, and the avatar is clear. However, it is small...the actual gif takes up maybe one third of the avatar. I'm kind of torn because I usuall don't like plain white backgrounds, but I have to admit it kind of works here...

Not the biggest fan of the style (stick figures...bleh ), but the quality is good, so it deserves an 8.0/10 (80/100).

seebach

• Attachment: seebachpic.jpg