| The Fallen Phoenix |
10-31-2004 05:07 PM |
Grunger Kittie Version 1: I can't really rate this avatar objectively, but I'll try...
The picture quality isn't horrible, but in all honesty it isn't all that great, either. The image is plagued by grain, which is understandable when one considers what kind of image it is...still, it certainly would be nice if the image were a little clearer. Then everyone would better appreciate that beautiful girl.
Quite the original image...both in its nature (it being an actual photo) and content. The border is also interesting...it's very thick and uses an unusual color. While I'm not really the biggest fan of said color, it is a nice touch...personally, I think a warmer color would suit the border better.
Overall, however, the avatar is pretty good.
Clarity: 7/10
Originality: 10/10
Color: 8/10
Stature: 7/10
Objective (weighted average): 8.3/10
Opinion (subjective): 10/10
Overall: 8.7
| Kittie heavenly6 |
10-31-2004 05:14 PM |
You Break my heart FP! Actually I made a few more Fairy avatars, I plan to rotate through them
Interesting thing about the border color, It almost matches the color of her corset! That's why I went with it!
FP:
What the hell IS your avatar? It's sexy whatever it is. The colors are really nice, and it's just beautiful. Easily a 10.
| Dude Love |
10-31-2004 07:20 PM |
GK: Token Girl! w00t!
First of all, bonus points because it matches your sig.
Well, anyway, though quality is lacking, the direction the image takes overall is good. 9.1/10.
| Piano Black |
11-01-2004 01:36 PM |
Didn't I rate your avatar already, Wienberg? Yeah, I think I gave it an 8 out of 10. Uhmm I think...
| Tifaria |
11-01-2004 07:42 PM |
Lemme know if I'm doing this wrong, 'cause I've only posted in this thread once or twice before.
Piano Black: I don't usually like "negative" pictures that much, but yours is at least something different, and I quite like the color scheme. The brightness on the right side is a little distracting, but it's not too bad. 8/10
And here's mine:
The images are from here, lyrics from Queen's "The Show Must Go On" (which I would love to make a Big-O video to one day.. but for now I'm just working on an icon set for my livejournal).
It's really good. Although I was all for Roger and Angel so I'm a little biased. It's a little bit grainy around Roger's shoulder but otherwise it is very good.
9/10.
| Darkside |
11-01-2004 08:36 PM |
GAT, I can't remember if I rted it but either way a 10/10 because Darth Vader rules!
| R.Smith |
11-02-2004 03:09 AM |
Darkside, SubZero rules, good quality: 10/10
I changed mine (again) to Xandir from "Drawn Together".
I was originally going to use this:
But I always like having something animated instead.
Though, if the still is better then I'll use that then.
| nathjan |
11-02-2004 03:29 AM |
"I'm on a quest to save my girlfriend" nice job R.Smith, 8.5/10
| Piano Black |
11-02-2004 10:52 AM |
nathjan, yuck. The quality isn't so great. -200/10.
| nathjan |
11-02-2004 11:12 AM |
Piano Black 3/10 for lack of orignality
nathjan the yummyness is soo nummy quality stinks 7/10
| Piano Black |
11-02-2004 03:57 PM |
Kittie Gurl Ebie, that's kinda cute. 8/10.
Piano Black it's diffrent I like it 9/10
| Asirt |
11-03-2004 05:40 PM |
It's been a while since I posted here...
Kittie Gurl Ebie,
Quality of image is good. The clarity could be better, but the animation is pretty good. Reminds me of R.Smith's old avatar. Anyway, I don't see any other problems, so I give it a 8.5/10
Piano Black,
Quality of image is good. It's a negative version of the original image, so it looks good. Could work on the clarity and the color contrast, though. Other than that, good job. I give it a 8/10
nathjan,
Quality of image is good. Clarity is pretty good, but the color contrast could use some work, in my opinion. It's a little grainy, but other than that it's good. I give it a 8/10
R.Smith,
Quality of animated image is good. It looks a bit grainy, but the animation is very smooth. The border fits the image quite well. I don't see any other problems, so I give it a 8.5/10
I'm going to change my avatar soon... I'm not sure what to use yet, so you will have to stick with rating my current one.
Later,
Trisa
| Christina Perry |
11-03-2004 06:29 PM |
Trisa: You need the JPG image for your avatar that I can see.
4/10 for you.
< New Avatar.
Rate it for me everyone.
| R.Smith |
11-03-2004 06:32 PM |
| quote: |
Originally posted by RogersGirl
Trisa: You need the JPG image for your avatar that I can see.
4/10 for you.
< New Avatar.
Rate it for me everyone. |
RogersGirl, everyone just can't change their avatar format to jpg just for you to be able to see it. There is something very wrong with either your browser or computer. Rating Trisa's avatar with a 4 just because you can't see it isn't fair.
Please look in to fixing your broswer/computer.
As for your current avatar 1/10, it's very blurry, and very grainy.
| Darkside |
11-03-2004 07:32 PM |
R.Smith: 10/10 Nothing but the best from the best of making avatars!
| Benjamin |
11-03-2004 08:12 PM |
| quote: |
Originally posted by Darkside
R.Smith: 10/10 Nothing but the best from the best of making avatars! |
you've got to be joking...(Laughs) Anyway, good avatar, AND IT MATCHES THE USER NAME!
9.5/10 *It Could Be A Bit Bigger*
5 MORE POSTS FOR DARKSIDE
Whoever Posts Next Please Rate This
| R.Smith |
11-03-2004 08:31 PM |
| quote: |
Originally posted by Benjamin
| quote: |
Originally posted by Darkside
R.Smith: 10/10 Nothing but the best from the best of making avatars! |
you've got to be joking...(Laughs) Anyway, good avatar, AND IT MATCHES THE USER NAME!
9.5/10 *It Could Be A Bit Bigger*
5 MORE POSTS FOR DARKSIDE
Whoever Posts Next Please Rate This |
Ok, the avatar you wanted rated is a little bit grainy in some areas, and the text color blends in too much with the avatar. 7/10
I cleaned up my current avatar a bit, so it shouldn't be as grainy as it was before.
