Rate The Avatar

COHugh 9.9/10 me likey!!!!! ) )

my 666 post!!!!

Kittie Gurl Ebie: Your avatar has a very goth dark tone it.

+ The colors are all drowned out, but it still manages to look good.
+ It in General looks cool.

- The Avatar is fairly thin compared to other Avatars, which kind of iffs me.
- I'm not sure what the avatar is of exactly, yes, it is a woman, but I'm not sure who the woman is, if she is anyone of note.

Overall: 800/1,000

... Um.. Avril Lavigne? The cutest punk rocker chick evar?

I'm slightly partial to Avril myself, so I have to say 8/10...

Hey! The punk look is cute! ::thpppppt::

Ok, I am having a problem here, people... I can't get my file to not darken when I convert from .psd to .png....

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHA!!!!!!!!!!!!

I found a better file format plugin for Photoshop that doesn't darken my image!!! Behold!

Old:


New:


I had to use a different cap of Kazuki and I repositioned heads, etc. Added a border as well.

Prons = Nice original artwork.

It's very nice! I love the brightness and the border. 9.5/10

COHugh,
New avatar looks better. The quality is good like the old one, and it's not as dark. The border has an added touch to it as well. However, I liked the placements of the characters' heads in the old one than in this one. Very good avatar overall. I give it a 8.5/10

Kittie Gurl Ebie,
The Avril avatar looks good, even though I'm not a big fan of her. Quality of image is cool, and the dark style makes it a good avatar. However, the letters in the left seem to distract the avatar. That's just me, though. I give it a 8/10

Seraphim,
The quality of image is great. This avatar of yourself seems to look very good. I also like the black border, even though that color is often use a lot. Great avatar, overall. I give it a 8.5/10

Later,
Trisa

Prons: (Skipping a few, I just really like prons av)

The image quality is good, looks a little blurry but not too bad. The edit of your SN on her hat is also really nice looking. it almost looks like part of the original pic

Overall, I'd say you did a good job with that one. I'll go ahead and since I am biased towards Nami, give you a 10 out of 10. Good job

quote:

Originally posted by Almasy Strange, my perfectly acceptable post from a few minutes ago has mysteriously disapeared.

quote:

Originally posted by R.Smith Ok, it has been brought to my attention (and I've noticed it myself) that lately many of you have not really been following the original "rules" set here: quote: Originally posted by Nein This is simple enough. Just rate the avatar of the member who posts above you, which in this case, would be me. Please, don't just say "That's awesome," you've gotta actually critique the avatar. So, yeah, have fun with it. I've seen many posts that either don't even bother to say why they gave the rating that they did. Please try and follow the rules.

NOTE: Try a little bit harder to know the rules, and look back a few posts. (If you don't like it, tough, then don't post.)

R. Smith, Complateing Crowboy. 9/10
GK. Cute & Classy Lady. 9/10

quote:

Originally posted by R.Smith quote: Originally posted by Almasy Strange, my perfectly acceptable post from a few minutes ago has mysteriously disapeared. quote: Originally posted by R.Smith Ok, it has been brought to my attention (and I've noticed it myself) that lately many of you have not really been following the original "rules" set here: quote: Originally posted by Nein This is simple enough. Just rate the avatar of the member who posts above you, which in this case, would be me. Please, don't just say "That's awesome," you've gotta actually critique the avatar. So, yeah, have fun with it. I've seen many posts that either don't even bother to say why they gave the rating that they did. Please try and follow the rules. NOTE: Try a little bit harder to know the rules, and look back a few posts. (If you don't like it, tough, then don't post.)

Ah, my mistake! ^__^

Anyway, on to my rating of your avatar, R.Smith:

I don't think I've ever rated this avatar before. First of all, I think it is a VAST improvement on your other blinking Roger avatar (I hated the plain gray background in that one).

The quality of your current avatar is very crisp and clear. However, it's almost too sharp in a way, if you know what I mean.

The blinking animation is definitely a bonus, since it blinks seamlessly. Also, I don't know much about GIF making, but you seem to have been able to retain almost 100% quality, even though it's an animated image!

The colors are very nice, and the blues in the sky behind Roger work well with your pink moderating stars.

I would like to have seen some kind of border (preferably black) though I'm aware that that is probably slightly more difficult when dealing with multipl-framed animated avatars.

All in all I would say this is an excellent avatar, with very few flaws.

You're overall rating is a solid 8.5/10! ^__^

Almasy:
+Its got a dark moody style to it.
+ The girl is attractive, even though I am a brunette person myself.
+ Its overall very pretty and has no empty corners, a border, and it fits you.

Overalll: 853/1,000

[Prons I said it before to TBDI, please stick to the 1-10 scale of rating.~R.Smith]

R Smith:

Image quality is good I like the colors, and the animation is nice. Good timing on it. I'll give it a 10.

Almasy:

Is that Paris? well as you know i was never a huge fan of hers, but I'll pay no mind to that for now.
The image looks nice, it does look Maniped a little, maybe to make her skin look nicer? I'm not sure if it's just my monitor or not though. Probably my favorite of all of your recent Avatars. Colors are nice and attractive and it's easy to look at. I'll give it a 10.

Could someone rate these Avatars for me:

Prons: I must say, I've noticed a vast improvement in your avatars over the last week or so. This avatar in particular is another in an impressive string...

Image quality is great...a very clear avatar, with some marvelous contrast and very little grain. The image does seem a little blurry, though...that's the only clarity flaw I could see.

It has some fairly original concepts...I like how you added "Prons" on the character's cap in a legible (but unique) font. I thought it was a very nice touch.

Use of color is fantastic, particularly the contrast. However, the "Prons" works as a double-edged sword, as I think the white color (while a perfect contrast to the black hat) seems too dull...I'm not denying that it works; I suppose it's just a personal preference, in the end.

One gripe I have with the avatar is the little grey object in the upper-right corner; it's quite distracting, and I think the avatar would greatly benefit from its removal.

All in all, it's a very solid avatar. Sharpen it, remove the object in the upper left-corner, and perhaps change the color of the text, and it'd be a real winner.

Clarity: 9/10
Originality: 8/10
Color: 9/10
Stature: 8/10

Objective (weighted average): 8.5/10
Opinion (subjective): 8/10

Overall: 8.4

As a note FP, what color would you like the text on her bandana to be?

As for your avatar.

+ Its clear.
+ It makes me feel like I'm playing Never Winter Nights.

- I don't like the turban.
- She is fairly homley, and overall not very cool looking in my opinion.

How ever, the avatar does kind of fit you. There fore I will bestow the rating of
8.7/10 upon you.

Grunger Kittie Version 1,
The quality of the avatar is good, and it seems to capture most of the girl in the avatar. I don't see any problems with it other than it looks a little grainy on the right side. Other than that, nice avatar. I give it a 8/10


As for this avatar, once again, the quality of the image is good. The only I don't like is the whiite line surrounding the girl. Good avatar nonetheless. I give it a 8/10


This one doesn't have the while line that the other avatar has, and the color contrast looks nice. Again, quality is nice. I give it a 8.5/10

R.Smith,
I like the new blinking Roger Smith avatar. Quality is very good, however, it doesn't seem very colorful. Then again, it is during the night, and there is a lot of dark colors in it. Great avatar overall. I give it a 8.5/10

Wingnut,
Quality of the Gundam unit is OK, but not the best. Also, although the transparency makes a nice touch, the white line surrounding the picture makes the avatar not as good as it could be. I give it a 7.5/10

Almasy,
Quality of image is great, although a bit dark. I also like the color contrast used on your avatar. It makes it have a different touch to it... I give it a 8.5/10

Later,
Trisa

G.K.: The two you posted are both 6/10. The quality is just really bad in my opinion. If you fixed that up, they'd easily be 8+/10.

Seraphim it is a good quality pic, so i'm gonna give it 8/10

The quality is only ok, but it has a big gun. Or a cool ship. Whatever, either way it's cool.
8/10.

GAT-X105:

Boy, I have not seen you in a while. As for your avatar

+ It is nicely centered.
+ Its high quality.
+ The backround is nice.

Overall: 8.6/10

Prons: Well, clarity wise, it's a bit (only a bit) off. A lot of the colors seem to bleed slightly out of their positions. This could possibly be solved by sharpening it a bit. Next, the colors work well. They contrast each other fairly well, although in my opinion not quite enough to stand out all too well. I think the center piece of this avatar, however, is "Prons" on the bandana. I would like to commend you (or, if you didn't make this, whoever did) on the fine editting job there. It looks as if it were originally there. However, it also falls victim to the slight color bleeding of the rest of the picture, and isn't nearly as sharp as it should be.

Overal rating:

8.6/10

Wienberg: Nice Sean Connery or Roger Moore avatar. I love Jame Bond movies. 10/10 for you.