Rate The Avatar

The Fallen Phoenix,
I like the contrast you used on the avatar, so it makes the avatar bright, yet show detail, unlike a lot of grayscale avatars I've seen in the past. Who is she, anyway? I give it a 9/10

GAT-X105,
Good job on clarity, but I don't know who that guy is. I give it a 8/10

Wienberg,
Nice avatar, but I seem to be a little distracted by that white border. I give it a 8/10

Later,
Trisa

Trisa: Another high-quality avatar, which is really what I've come to expect from you.

Clarity is nearly perfect. The only flaw I see (it's a flaw I seem to be getting quite good at recognizing...) is the presense of some miscolored pixels on the left side of the image, in her hair; but we're talking a very minute flaw that you can only see if you're looking for it. At first glance (and second and even third glance), the presense of those pixels really pass you by.

Still, that's not enough to warrent a lower clarity rating. The image quality is still deserving of a perfect rating, I think.

I love the colors used in this avatar...very crisp, and a nice use of color contrast contrast, particularly in regards to the blue strip on the left side of the image; it's a nice touch, and I personally like the split color background.

There's really not much more that can be said...very few flaws in this marvelous avatar.

Clarity: 10/10
Originality: 8/10
Color: 8/10
Stature: 9/10

Objective (weighted average): 8.9/10
Opinion (subjective): 10/10

Overall: 9.2

---
By the way, the girl in my avatar is none other than Eponine from the book (and musical) Les Miserables. It's my avatar for the month of September.

Every week, I'll change my user text and signature to reflect a new quote from the book; the only constants being that the quote will be from Les Miserables and refer to or include Eponine, who is by far my favorite character.

The Fallen Phoenix, 9/10 nice one, who is it?

Is it just me, or does Megatron look like he's made of stone?
The quality is good but Megatron makes you his bitch. 9/10.

(nobody knows who James Carville is? )

quote:

Originally posted by GAT-X105 Is it just me, or does Megatron look like he's made of stone? The quality is good but Megatron makes you his bitch. 9/10. (nobody knows who James Carville is? )

An Old Dude with glasses, Hmm 98/100 Because Of The little Loss of quality, a bit bluury.

~~~Benjamin~~~

quote:

Originally posted by GAT-X105 (nobody knows who James Carville is? )

GAT: I do! He came and spoke at our school last year! ^__^

9/10 because his speech was awesome!

Big Dou Inferno:

+ It Animates nicely, which is always a plus.

+ It seems of good quality.

- I can't see what it is very well, I have no idea what it is, and even if I did it has this big ol thing infront of it.

I'm afraid I have to give it 500/1,000 Its par, but I'm not very partial of it


Almasy:

+ Its Very Crisp Clear
+ The Guy looks like you.
+ The girl looks like Paris Hilton
+ It looks like Almasy and Paris Hilton making out.
+ I like Almasy.

- I don't really know anything about Paris Hilton, I never watched the Simple life or anyting shes been in. But she is attractive.

Overall: 900/1,000.

Prons Yours reminds me of my GF and so thats a instant 100/100 but I must say

THE BIG THING IN MY AVATAR IS THE FRACTAL CODE

Prons: 10/10, its clear, good quality blah, blah, blah. But I can't tell if its a guy or a girl. Damn you Hanson and your gender confusing looks!

quote:

Originally posted by Darkside Prons: 10/10, its clear, good quality blah, blah, blah. But I can't tell if its a guy or a girl. Damn you Hanson and your gender confusing looks!

Forgive me, but *SLAP* don't talk about Ellen Muth like that! >: (

And she's George from Dead Like Me, not Hanson.

Anyways..

Nice animated avatar. 9/10

quote:

Originally posted by Darkside Prons: 10/10, its clear, good quality blah, blah, blah. But I can't tell if its a guy or a girl. Damn you Hanson and your gender confusing looks!

That is a chick, and on Judgment day you shall be judged by your mistake.


ALL WILL BE JUDGED!

- Rhonda, from the 7th layer of YAR.

Black borders? yuck. It doesn't suit it. Besides I don't like the idea of avatars having sex on a public forum. 4/10

quote:

Originally posted by evanASF27 Black borders? yuck. It doesn't suit it. Besides I don't like the idea of avatars having sex on a public forum. 4/10

You have to have black borders, or else it just seems "open".

Furthermore, it looks more like they're singing than having sex.

Seraphim: Personally, I liked your Inuyasha avatars (both of them; the one of Sesshoumaru and the one of his inferior, half-breed brother) better than this one.

Clarity is a bit lacking, I think. While it is an animated image, which almost guarentees that it's going to have quality issues, it isn't a perfect alibi. The freedom slide in particular has a lot of grain, and the image (I'm presuming that's a woman?) isn't very clear. The words, for the most part, are clear enough to read..."freedom" is the hardest to read, but it's still legible.

The image does loop well; a lot of animated avatars don't, so that's a plus. Also, unlike other animated avatars, this has more of a slide-show feel to it, which gives it some originality.

I'm not a big fan of the colors used; beige is too boring for my tastes, though I will admit that's more of a personal preference than a technical issue. All of the slides are the same color, which helps. Still, I can't help but feel that more colors might have made the avatar a little better.

So, while I guess the color isn't bad, it isn't terribly good, either. It's merely average.

One of my biggest issues with the avatar is the size; it's a little too small for my tastes. While I know a lot of people would also comment on its lack of a border, I'm not one of those people who demands that every avatar ought to have a border; I think it's something that's optional. Size, however, is always an issue for me; while a small size can be forgivable if it's an animated image and/or the width:height is in a 1:1 ratio, I'm still not a big fan of small avatars.

Ultimately, it's not a bad avatar...it's original, but I think it gets hurt by the (relatively) poor quality and the small size.

Clarity: 6/10
Originality: 9/10
Color: 7/10
Stature: 6/10

Objective (weighted average): 7.3/10
Opinion (subjective): 6/10

Overall: 7

The Fallen Phoenix - [9 - 10] - The shadows make her look like she's half commando. Heh heh.

Sexi! 9/10

Nein, 10/10, great colors and it just looks really cool.

Super Umino, strange, 10/10, since I used to collect the cards.

R. Smith: 10/10. Smooth animation-wise, and very grain-free. Not much else to say.

Volt:
I never seen this avatar.
2.5/10