Episode 26 Discussion: "The Show Must Go On"

Name Of God 11-03-2003 12:30 AM
The history channel needs to do a three-part miniseries on this last episode of Big O.

I'll watch all three, and I still won't have a clue. Frown
s-girl 11-03-2003 12:35 AM
quote:
Originally posted by "Yeah, but..."


Dorothy and Angel are definitely drawn differently, but I think Dorothy is still an android. Angel blinks a few times, while Dorothy doesn't. I think this is intended to show that Dorothy is still an android. Plus, she's still pale.



The promo art I posted for the DVD release features a similar type look...

My assumption is that It might just be that someone else was tasked with drawing this little snippet and that the style change wasn't intentional. Consider that everything else was just rehashed from the 1st episode.

It really bugged me though... even the blinking was really artificial.
(Bad animator, bad bad bad!)
DominusofMegaDeus 11-03-2003 12:50 AM
can anyone explain why was dorothy in the control room with angel at the end and said roger the negiotator? I am confused. but I thought the episode was great but very confusing. I really want a season 3. but the joke at the start with stripes had me worried but was suprised when it slowed down and then went to the cards.
Akyla 11-03-2003 01:02 AM
Wow, what i'm saying is actually making sense to someone else. Usually I go on strange tangents and lose everyone.

The more i think about this show in full the more i see it as a cross between the Truman show and Matrix with big robots.

The ppl who are actually in control of the mega deuces have an ability outside the others to manipulate the surroundings. The ppl have an awareness the others don't even if they don't have their memories.

I keep thinking about what scrolls across Big O's screen. I think in the japanese verson it's "Forged in the name of God therefore it is not a sin." It makes me wonder if that's refering to Big O who is the only one standing up against the other mega deuces, or is it the entire city, or is it refering to the "tomatoes"? Gordon even comments that the new batch is almost ready (or harvest.can't remember). This could be a sign that it's time to start over with a new batch of humans.

I think Big O's purpose in general to protect the ppl. Roger can't figure out why he has control of Big O, i think he only realizes at the end. Once again the ppl who control the mega deuces have a greater awareness. It makes me wonder if Big O is activated (by angel prolly) and therefore contacts Roger. Roger and Angel have a connection, that's for sure. Is he like Angel? Angel controlling from the outside, Roger from the inside. Is Dorothy so much a being of her own or a device for Angel to communicate to Roger when things get excessively bad. Angel did have a protective attitude toward Dorothy. Dorothy does have connections to two megadueces..prolly more. Therefore she was created at the same time they were maybe.

And to add to my earlier thoughts of the outside world being destroyed, at the beginning of episode 20, they show Big Ben mostly buried under the sand.

And this ends my rambling for this post.
s-girl 11-03-2003 01:08 AM
quote:
Originally posted by DominusofMegaDeus
can anyone explain why was dorothy in the control room with angel at the end and said roger the negiotator? I am confused. .



In the Japanese version, Dorothy states "Roger Smith, Negotiator" and not "Roger the Negotiator."

It serves more as an introduction... but still doesn't address the "why" at all.

Some folks stated in other threads that this Roger is the Roger we see in the rewrite. I don't really know what to think. It sort of fits in with the actors/theatre analogy and might explain why we see Dorothy interspersed not in her green dress but her black outfit. (Meaning the Dorothy in the control room is the same that we see with Angel a few seconds later.)

*headache*
Nyarlathotep 11-03-2003 01:09 AM
Something occured to me after watching act 26 again. Everytime Big O rises and fights, entire city blocks are leveled, and no one seems to ever notice after it happens. Maybe this is because their memories are selectively altered and new hologram buildings replace the ruined ones...
Sixfortyfive 11-03-2003 01:13 AM
quote:
Originally posted by s-girl
In the Japanese version, Dorothy states "Roger Smith, Negotiator" and not "Roger the Negotiator."


No, she says "Rojaa za Negoshieitaa." Basically the same thing as "Roger the Negotiator." Cut the Japanese some slack; they don't have the "th" sound in their language.
Jr. 11-03-2003 01:27 AM
Ok, I got to see about 15 minutes of it with no sound. I don't think I would understand it anyway.
The lack of closure in season 1 was different than this. This is just wierd. If anyone can answer these:


1) What happened at the end?

2) What is this huge grid everything starts disappearing on?

3) What was that big robot at the end?

4) What does this mean? Was it all a movie?

5) Why were Angel and Dorothy drawn strangely at the end?

6) So is "our" Roger gone or dead?
Akyla 11-03-2003 01:32 AM
okay, commercial break, heh.

When beck says "what are memories?" Norman replies (forgive a not perfect quote) "Memories are a human condition." Is Norman human? He does have the knowledge to fix Big O, well him and that crew of his wherever they go.

The memories he sees include a factory that built the mega dueces i think. They destroyed the outside world and prolly set off some natural disators. If a world had the technology to creat the mega dueces, i think they could create a holodeck soundstage. Roger being able to be in there and in the control room could easily be that's the real him the control room and the other just a projection.

I'm still debating btwn Angel got lost in her own reality, creating all this and there really is an outside world. A Matrix thing where she doesn't realize she's dreaming it all until the very end. It's just her nightmare and everyone was trying to get her to face the reality and ofc if it was her dream she wouldn't want to be the only one without memories of who she was.
Or if there was an apocolyse and they are all that are left and she and a few others built this world Maybe they anticipated it and were ready when the destruction came.
mushdog 11-03-2003 01:32 AM
About the final scene; maybe the megadueses were removed in the next rewrite (by whoever the directors are, probably Angel, Roger, Beck, and Dorothy). Since Roger seemingly convinces Angel (the current director) that memories aren't necessary, and the people, incluidng himself, selected to lose their memory, why have the megaduses (those which contain the memories)? Also, many die because of the megadues battles, and if the memories are no longer necessary, neither are the megadueses.

Some problems; Roger still calles Paradigm "the city of amnesia," which alludes to the fact that people still search for memories. However, he's not wearing his watch, which means the megaduses have been removed (and then the people would never know the truth, even though they desire the truth) or he hasn't found Big O in the rewrite yet.

I don't understand why Dorothy is in the control room though. The final episode made it seem as though this was all a story written up by Angel, and brought to life by virtual reality. The actors are sort of in a "Matrix" thing, where they play out their roles, and then it loops. They don't really exist, they're just personalities developed by artificial intelligence (hence the robot copies of roger). Angel wanted to place herself in the production, so created a manifestation of herself, hoping to develop a relationship with the leading man (Roger). Maybe on some level she grew fond of this character, developing him as the play went along, and wanted to act out a fantasy. Assuming this, who is the "real" Dorothy, and why is she in the control room? Maybe Angel and Dorothy are the directors, and Dorothy got Roger this time???


That's all I got. If someone could explain the significance of Big Venus (is that what caused the Event, or was that used to defend Earth from the leviathans after the armies of Bigs failed?), that be awesome.
neverwhere 11-03-2003 01:35 AM
The theory by Penny Century is actually the one I'm leaning towards right now; that Dorothy is the director now.

Why? I dunno (It's late!). I guess for all the reasons stated, plus, It just makes more sense that way.

Oh, and BTW, Adult Swim: The ten seconds of Stripes before the show started was NOT funny.
"Yeah, but..." 11-03-2003 01:36 AM
After watching it a second time...

I believe Roger is "making contact" with "the director of this world" when he starts shouting at Big Venus. It's quite possible that Roger's end monologue to Angel is "on tape", which is a plausible reason why Angel is reviewing all of those times she interacted with Roger on the mini screens. Roger does talk about the relationship he developed with her in the monologue...Dorothy introduces Roger in the control room because Roger now is meeting with Angel face-to-face to begin the negotiations. We don't actually see the negotiations on screen.

Now, what was agreed upon during those negotiations?
olliefu 11-03-2003 01:44 AM
So after waiting another week for this episode, it finally aired with a nice joke...anyhow like everyone..im confused as well. the visuals are great...so what do i conclude from this...

It ends like a French Film...very far fetch...

There's something about Angel that we dont know...maybe shes the controller of the world and she seeks some sort of romance with a fictious chracter name roger smith..however its characters liek dorothy that disrupts the love between them 2...its wierd i know..but i have no clue in how to conclude this season..will there be a season 3?! beats me...

Oh one other thing..do you notice that the bar dude where roger gets his info is an android..maybe this world is all ficticious..it has layers and layers of stroies...liek somethign mention like the Matrix and Thruman Show...Maybe there all stuck in the Matrix and then must free there minds...oh wells...my head hurts..going to bed
Akyla 11-03-2003 01:47 AM
Maybe the entire show is the creators long drawn out way of saying: Technology is taking over our lives, we are lost in it and it will destroy us if we do not face reality. The use of the TV's at the end and control room is a metaphor for the world of couch potatoes and net addicts (yeah i know, i'm describing myself too) that are living vicariously through characters on TV or avoiding real physical contact. Angel is Lucifer which is an easy way to convey evil to everyone and therefore Lucifer is technology.
mushdog 11-03-2003 01:52 AM
I also noticed that he was an android, which makes sense, when you think about it. From previous episodes, the androids and megaduses (sentient machines, in general) are the ones that contain the memories. Roger's contact seems to know a lot for a person who's supposed to have amnesia along with the rest of them, especially knowledge about the past. He knows so much beacuase he hasn't lost his memories, because he's not human.

What does everyone think about my theory on the final episode (its a few posts above)?
BlitzballMaester 11-03-2003 01:59 AM
Okay here's my theroy on the Big O ending.

Roger Smith was the pilot of the Big Venus, he reset Paradigm city 40 years ago(for some unknown reason, however its highly hinted there was a major war of sometype and the BIGS are similar to todays tanks) and gave control/created Angel to pilot/become Big Venus and erased his own memories. "To live in the present and Future." (His own words) To start anew. However, himself and others retainted certain memories of the past includin how to operate pilot the BIGS (we see many people piloting BIGS/ creating operating Arch types throughout the show,) These people are refered to as tomatoes by Gordon Rosewater(someone whom Roger knew and trusted which is why he left Gordon with some knowledge of the tomatoes/Big Venus/Angel and himself) ....some people the knowledge was good and in others I.E those in the employ of the Union and Alex the knowledge was peverted. Things play out and the good tomatoes are sperated from the bad ones. Which leads us full circle, Big Venus(or rather its pilot/manifistation Angel) seeing how people peverted the memeories decided things needed to be restarted again, she remade the world. When she was remaking the world she was asked which Roger she wanted to spend the next cycle with. Roger the Wanderer, Roger the Negotiator<sp?>, or Roger the Dominus<sp?> of Megadus<sp?> SO she's not really in a control room at the end of the show rather its her mind (IE: the monitors show her past spent with the varying forms of Roger, and she's crying because she is learning that she and Roger had been together before the event.) Now Dorothy could be either a.)asking a question to which she thinks is the best choice for Angel. "Roger the Negotiator?" or b.) Dorothy is simply stating that Roger the Negotiator is the one Angel chooses. The world resets with Roger the Negotiator as the "main character" again.



( Now, I personally hope that they leave it at 26 episodes, they could do what they did with Evangelion and do a movie type of project which helps clear up minor technicalities in the show.)

I believe that this should be/is the last season due to the fact that a.) Roger did not have his Big O watch on once the world reset. b.) there was the "We Have Come To Terms. at the end of the episode.

What sums this show up best is the line from epsiode 13
"These tomatoes are reproduced synthetically, with only the memories of the sweet flavorful original. If we keep repeating the process, this fruit will eventually become the real thing."- Gordon Rosewater

Basically the way things had been going is that Big Venus had been resetting things for quiet some time, leaving each generation with memeories of the previous one till one generation can come to terms or fix what happened to cause Big Venus to be nesscary in the first place. Each time it resets things there is a new director/pilot to Big Venus, who is then cast into society to judge weigh humanity unaware.
Angel saw what she and Roger had been once and wanted to be with Roger the Negotiator the one she loved. At that time Venus granted her wish along with resetting things and a new pilot was chosen.

<then again it just could be that I'm a romatic at heart and the creators as well as fans were sick of seeing the "everyone dies" ending. They could have done the "draw your own meaning" to the end of the show without the "everyone dies" cliche (insert Evangelion headache/debate over the end comment here)<FYI: I only mock it because I love it> ^^
Executor 11-03-2003 02:00 AM
This sucked.
Roger the Wanderer 11-03-2003 02:14 AM
I finally got to see the episode, since I live so far west. I believe the best possible response after watching that is "HUH?!?"

Does this remind anyone of the Eva ending, where they just ended abruptly?

Well, onto the episode. Aside from the ending, very awesome, though I think I still like Act 14 better.

Big O's final stage was huge! Man, no other Megadeus, Big or otherwise can possiblly compete with that, since it quite literally nuked everything in its path.

I really hope there's a 3rd season, or at least a OVA or movie to explain all the loose ends.

Hm, makes me wonder who truly knows the truth behind Paradigm City? Gordon Rosewater seems to have a pretty good idea about what'll happen, or at the very least, he knew about the Director (probably Angel). Though Schwarzwald seems to have found out about it at the end.

Strange to see Big Ear after so long, just to see that he's an android too just before he's crushed by a falling beam (I assume)

Nice to see that Big O and Roger still have a good partnership. Big Fao looks like it was half ready to strangle Rosewater, just like Big Duo did to Alan Gabriel. But when Big O tried to do it, it actually listened to Roger and stop.

And though Dorothy has been out of action for a few eps, she had some of the best lines! I loved her "You're a louse," and "A buffoon with curly hair and gaudy clothes" lines.

Surprising that of all people, Beck tells Dorothy of Big O's ultimate attack. Then again, even though the Greatest Villain seemed just like comic relief, it was strange how much Beck knew so much about how Big O worked, what with the watch and actual copy of Roger's vocal cords. Funny how in the end, though he hates both Alex Rosewater and Roger Smith, he'd prefer Roger win, and it was fun watching his feet clap.

Do all Bigs try to absorb their Dominuses? In Act 24, Roger told Allan Gabriel that incomplete Megadeuses seek out pilots to activate them. Then, Big Duo Inferno strangled him to death, but it seems that Schwarzwald told it too, but later on Roger says that Big Duo betrayed Schwarzwald. Ah, this is all very confusing.

Man, Dastun rocked! A few eps back Roger said that Dastun couldn't do anything, but this time he helped and gave Roger enough time to wake up. And its nice to see the military police grow some backbone. People have been calling them dogs of Paradigm for the entire series, and finally, they decide to follow Dastun, even if it was to their deaths.

I'm still really confused right now, but at least the series is finally over! Though I still hope for a 3rd season now since the ending was so confusing!
remo williams 11-03-2003 02:51 AM
Well,
I've been following some other people's theories for months now, its nice to see where things were spot on, as well as where they went WAY off Smile -all part of the fun i suppose.


Reality TV at its Finest (and thus we participate in the production)

I believe what we see is more accurately represented by an entity such as The Truman Show, perhaps with the actors interfacing in a much more matrix-like context. The religious overtones also offer some intriguing aspects, as I had already come to the conclusion that Norman was akin to John the Baptist.

but back towards the final episode- I am currently entertaining thoughts that angel fell in love with one of the actors, and perhaps some of the players are modeled after people in the "real world." They have incentive to bring in the ratings, lets say, and thus someone like Norman excites a certain element amongst the coconspirators as well as those who aren't in on it. Thus it would seem perfectly reasonable that people are genetically engineered to be extras with no prior knowledge of say, the outside world. Reality is what they live in- the here and now.
Angel seems to be the producer of this entire production, perhaps even "diving into" the play to interact with the participants/ check on the progress /illicit some sort of response to stimuli in order to propel the plot.

the other revelation is that the world consists of nothing more than holograms leading me to believe that even big venus and big o are nothing more than a physical manifestation of a mental state. well, at least it makes sense in the context of roger and angel. Matrix tie ins follow nicely as well, since I have the distinct impression that this season's "Roger, the negotiator" has made an exciting decision contrary to the normal ebbe and flow of events- his self-actualization is on some level different from the choices of his predecessors...and thus angel comes into the show, and his life, to grasp what may be taking place. Now I cannot say with any certainty whether or not she has an actress that portrays her on the inside or, as I suspect, she dives into the holo-world (which could be 13th floor style- all in a computer).
Perhaps this is the difference- angel falls in love with this Roger, he's certainly not the same as the last iterations, and therefore the finale is sad in a way- Haven't we all been sad to see a show end, a character killed off, had a crush or a fondness for a character in say, (i'm throwing stuff out here) ER, or the Real World. We follow these shows (such as Big O) and come to identify with a certain character- perhaps living vicariously through such events, or becoming attached to a certain character based on any number of illogical factors. I have, over the course of the year, watched many forum goers here root for angel and dorothy for roger's significant other.

Roger and dorothy would logically be explained then as protagonists, possibly even production assistants. They interact with the other players but these guys know the whole script- until Roger starts to write his own! And so Norman makes a statement as they attempt to repair the big-o prop again, perhaps longing for a second season within the current continuity...but this is not to be, the show must start fresh every season.

merchandising is everything- and as a side note, I enjoyed seeing the little dorothy' doll, which means that this show has reached a certain level of popularity among the viewing public. It seems almost reflexive, perhaps a bit of self-deprecation, but Big O certainly is a reality TV show, taken to extreme measures. And like any good show, touching on religious themes as well as cultural artifacts serves to pique the audience interest and draw them into suture through an unconscious association with said symbols.

people getting genetically engineered as extras, a gigantic holographic set complete with robots, a beautifully crafted back story spread by those "in the know" and elevated to the status of myth by the pawns. I would submit this show is pretty much what it seems on the surface, digging to deeply will likely produce nothing of substance, but my one timid interpretation does go like this:

this is a social commentary on the state of reality TV, perhaps with some sci-fi thrown in. It is indeed dark an sinister as the producers possibly have little value on human life. In other words, the fail-safes that protect people in the holo-stage have been turned off allowing for injury and even death.
this means that all the tomatoes (which in itself is no more significant a term of description than that of the 'pawn') are expendable. perhaps bred for such an evil purpose. So we could conclude by logical extension that the show caters to the lowest aspects of humanity and brings the worst out in people. (evidence of this would be the megalomaniacal Rosewater, and the willingness of the producers to exploit death and misery for ratings).
Such an evil show must have a foil, hence Roger, who offers some redeeming sort of value while still allowing the viewer to participate in the seedier aspects of the show without guilt. (think cops or joe millionaire).

Perhaps this is where we're headed? A society in which human life is of very little value, ratings are paramount, and the machinations of a heroic figure are glossed over in light of the new season. Would the show be so popular ending on a high note? Would principled characters draw a compelling story? My feeling is no; without drama and perhaps the seemly side of life, this show wouldn't be nearly as popular or have dorothy dolls. <hehe>.
At times the reality shows that we watch now invoke a certain amount of horror and repulsion. I can see that the shows bring out the best and worst in the human spirit, often at the same time. But we soon become desensitized to mental abuse and lust for "a bit of the old ultra-violence." I would not be in the least surprised if we were to see human executions and other ghastly acts televised in a few years- possibly even held as 'normal.' Sure we cringe at this now, but consider the travesty that is "When animals attack" and "World's scariest police Chases." Both of these scrape the proverbial bottom of the barrel- and yet we watch them, perhaps placated into a false sense of security by some redeeming element (such as Roger in the case of the Paradigm City Show, or the bad guys getting arrested on COPS). The fact that we slowly grow to accept these things as normal is disturbing.

and this is my only attempt at interpretation, because I feel that reaching any deeper would be a stretch or an over-interpretation. My own thoughts to this end could be on the fringe of acceptable translation so I shall entertain other thoughts and discussion to this end. Is it a comment culturally? I think so.

Coming back home though, I believe my impressions of the show are accurate, with players involved that are ignorant alongside those with intimate knowledge of the whole script. Roger made a decision that had not been planned on that brought everyone in the production cast to appreciate this season a bit more (think Neo choosing Trinity over the lives of those in the matrix). PLEASE NOTE: his decision was probably not outside of the scope for the show. The world and its occupants consist of people from outside as well as those genetically engineered for the specific purpose of populating the world (unless my next point bears out in a third season). The construction of the world is engineered via a holographic set, possibly aided by androids/ cyborgs. CERTAIN People could possibly be holograms too- explaining why the "ghost in the machine" becomes self aware and questions it's identity (i.e. angel being a memory of the producer). Makes sense. The Bigs and all objects are also holograms, but perhaps akin to Gene Rodenberry's interpretation and execution on the enterprise holo-deck: Capable of causing harm should the safeties be removed. Possibly controlled by a computer who gives computer based life forms the ability to be self aware. The only question is what is real? I personally think even the bigs are a manifestation of their pilots, perhaps some extension of deep-seated desires, possibly the Id. almost everything is a hologram. So we see that Dorothy can love, and perhaps other holo-beings yearn for life- despite the fact that they are expendable- which Roger comes to realize?! the more I think about it, the more this explanation makes sense.


memories are thus, a tool by which everyone measures their humanity and their quest for the answer to that all important question. The scope of the show seems deceptively simple, but we come to understand and recognize the human condition subconsciously. The show couldn't realistically support another season as it stands now since we know that in the end, it will all reset again. Perhaps a spinoff in which alternate choices/ universes are explored would be more appropriate, and I understand that a manga explores these ideas. is this correct? I am perfectly fine with the ending, im sure to the chagrin of many on the board here- I couldn't imagine what is left to do that would require another thirteen episodes. -but hey thats me.

Roger negotiates, er, asks for an extension, but "the show must go on."

-Quenton
margarita678 11-03-2003 03:24 AM
Ok here's what I think was going on.
Angel was in love with Roger, but Roger chose Dorothy instead. So Angel decided to create a world where Roger would choose her. She made Dorothy an android, so she couldn't feel love (didn't work), but left herself the tragic figure. If you notice in the scene where Angel is looking at the moniters, Roger (the real Roger) puts his hand on her shoulder with Dorothy behind him. I think she is dissapointed/depressed that she couldn't make Roger love her in her own play, so she rebooted it. I think Roger the Negotiator failed, because it didn't have a resolution and they are back where they started.
I felt really dissapointed with this episode. I wanted something more concrete. And what about Dotson and the movie theather?! I definitly think they are not going to have a season three, and the actors are going to be forced to play their parts forever.