Envy or Greed?

If you had to choose between Envy or Greed which one would you choose. Envy is my choice!!

quote:

Originally posted by Miyavi If you had to choose between Envy or Greed which one would you choose. Envy is my choice!!

I would take Greed in a goddamn second over Envy. I hate Envy with such a passion it is not even funny, and pardon the language but Envy is such a little bitch that tries unsuccessfully to be a dude. Oh, the anger that resides in me when I think about Envy.

Greed had such a cool and fresh aura about his persona that he was the homonculi guys wanted to be and the homonculi girls wanted to be with.

Anyway, Greed. Definetly...
Peace.

Well... Envy does get some points in my book for both the way he killed Hughes, and for beating Ed's ass. However, I will have to go with Greed here before he was way sweeter than any of the other six.

greed. because he turns me on. big time.

quote:

Originally posted by Gato Gurl914 greed. because he turns me on. big time.

O_O! oh Gato. =P

Envy is so freaking lame. I don't know why people like him. He's not that great a villain, he really only serves to A.) Pull some strings behind the scenes and B.) Manage to NOT DIE multiple times. Plus, for the people who think he is "hot", you should know he doesn't REALLY look like that. In reality

spoiler (highlight to read):

He looks like this

And, his reasons for being evil are lame as well.

spoiler (highlight to read):

DADDY NEVER HUGGED ME!!!

Greed was awesome all around. He did his own thing, and even though he was never really evil, he made a darn fine bad guy. Plus, he gets all the ladies, has an awesome gang, and is a sexy beast (this coming from a totally heterosexual male). He is even cooler in the manga, and even though he is only in maybe 2 chapters, he reallly makes an impression. Yea, Greed wins hands down.

Guess you all already knew I was going to say that though.

Envy hands down!!!

Envy is not a behind the sences. If you want a behind the sences, look at Lust who caused Greed's death. That appearance Envy so called has is in the manga, thats not the anime. For gosh sake he is a androgynous male, he feels comfortable in a adorable form. If Envy wasn't loyal to Lust's orders, as he's assigned to follow he would have killed the Elrics already, burned down Central, and at the end have a human body. Greed was younger then Envy, a humonculi tooken over by money, women, and plessures of a normal life.

Envy and Greed are bitter enemies. I like Envy alot better because, no matter how long it takes he doesn't try to forget what he is. Unlike Greed who uses simple plessures human's enjoy to feel human hiself. Down fall he didn't know his own downfall would kill him. Dante. Envy would have noticed that, Greed didn't being tricked like that it was simple for Lust to trick him. For the bond he feels from the women who made him what he is. Along with the little gang he has, a bunch of chimeras. I do like the fact he has some company which makes him loyal and cares for his loyal members. Though that is true, Envy is still my favorite character. He is loyal, adorable, and a proud humunculi.

Envy's true reasons for his evil attitude is not because he wasn't hugged when he was a child.

spoiler (highlight to read):

Envy held a great hatred toward Hohenheim for never being acknowledged by the man as his son and for abandoning him and Dante, with whom he had a rocky relationship. But by the time he learned that Hohenheim remarried and fathered two sons, Envy was even more furious and took it out on his younger half-brothers, Ed and Al, as it was the next best thing to killing their father.

heh i'm not all rainbows and lollipops.

quote:

Originally posted by Gato Gurl914 heh i'm not all rainbows and lollipops.

Huh?

Greed. Envy is propably the worst character on the show. With the exception of Kimblee.

greed is cooler but hey, wtf do I know, i've only seen about 3 episodes

quote:

Originally posted by Captain Harlock Greed. Envy is propably the worst character on the show. With the exception of Kimblee.

Tsk Tsk, did you forget about Wrath? Envy far surpasses Wrath.

quote:

Originally posted by Greed quote: Originally posted by Captain Harlock Greed. Envy is propably the worst character on the show. With the exception of Kimblee. Tsk Tsk, did you forget about Wrath? Envy far surpasses Wrath.

My mistake. It goes Envy, Kimblee, Wrath on the list of crappy characters

quote:

Originally posted by Miyavi quote: Originally posted by Gato Gurl914 heh i'm not all rainbows and lollipops. Huh?

sorry that was for gaddes.

I don't understand why everyone thinks Kimbly is such a crappy character? To me, he is the perfect villain since most people can't wait to see him get killed. It's also cool to see how much he fit into Scar's story.

quote:

Originally posted by Raven I don't understand why everyone thinks Kimbly is such a crappy character? To me, he is the perfect villain since most people can't wait to see him get killed. It's also cool to see how much he fit into Scar's story.

The reason so many people hate Kimblee, is because he betrays Greed, at least that's why I despise him.

He's not necessarily a bad character, true he is a good villian, but it's odd that they made a character that does not even appear in more than 3 panels in the manga, and has a relatively small role in the show, the most dispicable villain. Though, he's not as bad as the anime version of Bradley (Pride), he becomes a guy you just love to hate. His version in the manga (Wrath) is far more likable and far cooler, even though he captures Greed and causes his death.

I'd have to say Greed. I like my men manly even when they are evil.

I'm going to say Envy because he can be androgenous.

>_>

<_<

I'm ready for ALL comments.

I gotta go with Greed , He was a soulless, evil, manipulative, greedy bastard , who aquired a following of loyal men and women willing too die for him .Even Ed cried when Greed died ,that kind of charisma is too be admired .

I liked Kimbly too he was Nihilistic and demented but very good at what he did ...wich was blow stuff/people up . only reson some ppl dont like him is because he betrayed Greed .

I agree with Xero-Hour, greed is best