Rate the Avatar

Evan, one of my favorites from last year. 10/10

R.Smith, funny, 'stache almost looks like it belongs there, but a little low quality 8/10.

It might be hard to tell but I've joined in the April Fool's hijinks!

quote:

Originally posted by Lt. Sanji Evan, one of my favorites from last year. 10/10 R.Smith, funny, 'stache almost looks like it belongs there, but a little low quality 8/10. It might be hard to tell but I've joined in the April Fool's hijinks!

Actually, it does belong there, that was part of the "outfit". (bad quality due to it being a screen cap).



Lt. Sanji, good edit! 9.5/10

R.Smith = 8/10 due to the quality.

Changed mine. Roy with a Fake mustache given to him by Armstrong.
I wish I knew of the scan yesterday, it would have been great ^^; ....

Oh if you want, rate my April fools avatar, too:

Ha ha! I'm going to rate both!

The April Fools one is too cute! Roy with kitty ears...(grwwr) Armstrong with antennae? hehehe
They only flaw really is in that there are too many characters in such a small space. (sigh) 9/10

I like the current one also. The whole idea of him having Armstrong's mustache. LOL!!! It's very clear who it is. I'm not sure the green border works as well with this one 8.5/10

Madrona: 8/10

The resizing sorta killed the pic slightly, and the border isn't really fitting with the color scheme. Red, Black, or Dark Blue would have worked.

Ensign Minneapolis: The picture quality is good, and nice text placement. It also looks fine without a border. The only suggestion I would make is to lessen the JPEG compression a little (or use PNG format), since the compression adds a little distortion around the text. 8.5/10

Krang,
Quality of image is very good. There isn't any grain at all in this avatar. I seem to like the mood of the image as well. The clarity is also well done. Overall, it's an excellent avatar. I give it a 9/10

Ensign Minneapolis,
Quality of image is very good. There isn't any grain on the image (with the only exception being the text, but that's pretty minor). The text fits with the avatar's theme. Overall, great job. I give it a 9/10

Madrona,
Quality of image is very good also. No grain is present here, and the borders fits well with the image. Clarity is very nice, and the artwork is great. Overall, nice job. I give it a 9/10

Green_Bird,
Quality of image is pretty good. There isn't any grain at all, and the clarity is alright. The green works good with the image; perhaps try using a different color and see what the result will be. Overall, you did a great job. I give it a 9/10

Later,
Trisa

Krang:
10/10. Not perfect, simply because its a bit drab, but a good 10/10 either way.
Trisa:
I cannot notice any grain, the clarity is sharp, and the pose is unique to what Ive seen so far. Somethings missing though...and it prevents me from giving you that extra point. 9/10.

BigOZ - 8 out of 10

A very interesting yet unique new avatar you have here. However, the darkened blue colors distort the image somewhat. I am also oblivious as to where it is from, but it does coordinate well with your signature theme.

Avenir: Looks like a cross between an Episode II battle droid and a Cylon trooper. Background makes me wonder where it is. 10/10

Wingnut: I like the straight view of the face, it's really eye catching. 10/10

EVVVIIILLLL!!!!! @__@ ...but also kinda interestin O.o 7.77/10

Evan: The quality is not all that great. Though, this is probably simply due to the age of the film that is taken from, it is clearly of poor quality.

However, I am a fan of black and white avatars. I've always liked Black and White films a lot, and seeing a black and white avatar (of a black and white film) is always a breath of fresh air.

Other than the quality, my other complaint would be that the border does not stand out clearly enough. You could probably scrap it completely, or make it darker.

Rating: 8.2/10

Wienberg, what can I say, tis Pope John Paul II, automatic 10/10.

Figured I'd change my avatar, I still love ReBoot, I just wanted something more "eyecatching".


Original image used for avatar was done by tremorwave, and can be found here.

R. Smith - 10 out of 10

I must say, your new avatar is smashingly flawless. The dark tone is very felicitous for the image, the clarity is excellent, and it matches your signature perfectly. This warrants a very solid 10 out of 10.

I have no idea what it is (is it an advanced machine from the end of AI?), but it's pretty sweet. 9/10

Indeed it is. If you look around on A.I. DVD disc two, you can find it somewhere in the concept art.

Cerpin Taxt - 9 out of 10

I'm oblivious as to where it's from, but I'm assuming it's a horse. The artwork is interestingly nice and the enhanced dimensions make it stand out. A border would probably make it stand out further. Quite an exotic image.

It's very interesting, so it does seem to stick out. Very nice, I give it a 9/10

Hmm...an interesting avatar at that. I'm suprised someone's using a horror flick avatar here...well anyways onto the evaluation. The color is suprisingly better than some of the other avatars I've seen (it isn't too intense or as bright which is very good in my opinion). The portrayed emotion seems pretty well expressed in the picture as well. Personal preferences aside, I like it. 9/10