Rate the Avatar

quote:

Originally posted by Juvenile Angel But I can barely tell what it is (in terms of what the pictures of, it has nothing to do with quality). I'm going to guess it's a helicopter, since its just a shadow-like thing.

quote:

Originally posted by Aircraftkiller I really can't tell what your avatar is, but logically it's the helicopter-looking machine in your signature. It looks like it's part of a movie, or a 3D model. Either way it's very well done, although a bit of clarifying on the helicopter\ship\transport in your avatar would make it look even better.

Indeed, it is helicopter, as also pictured in my signature only hovering around instead. Yes, it is from a movie; the amphibicopter from A.I. - Artificial Intelligence to be exact. It would be brighter, but I couldn't enhance the color tones without distorting the image.

Aircraftkiller - 9 out of 10

A rather interesting image, and very good in clarity. The only fault is that I am completely oblivious as to where it is from. However, it is a very nice avatar.

Don't care much for Paris but that's a good picture and its centered and it has nifty border so I give it a 9.75/10.

Lt. Sanji: I really like the avatar. It may be lacking in quality (I'll explain in a few moments), but I like what you were going for. The simplicity is a breath of fresh air.

However, there are some major clarity issues. A lot of grain all across the image. It really detracts from the avatar, and is especially noticeable due to the high presence of white.

So, while I really like it, for quality issues I cannot give it much higher than a 6.6/10.

I know what went wrong....stupid Paint messing up my avatar...grr...

I fixed it up a little. Hopefully it looks better.



GAH! So little difference...my eyes hurt....

Lt. Sanji:
That is a nice avatar. Not really clear, with noticable grain(And my eyes are crud). The picture is redeeming though. Gives you a bit of personality.
6/10.

Wienberg:

I honestly prefered your clint eastwood one a while back, but this one is quite exceptional. Matches with your sig, colors are easy on the eyes, gives me a warm fuzzy feeling inside..
10/10. Not a perfect 10/10(As I gave to JA), but still. I know my avatars grainy like hell, dont blame me. I simply MS Paint-ed it out of one of the doujinshi pics.

i dont think its that bad: it matches your sig, and looks ok. it isn't too bright or flashy, so it;s easy on the eyes. The Beauty of Simplicity. i give it an 8/10

Captain Maw: It's too small, I'm afraid, and the image quality is not very good. 5/10. I suggest going for the full 100 X 100.

BigOZ: Again, this is an avatar that could be the entire 100 X 100. Although the picture itself is very adorable, I think it should be bigger. 6/10.

Lt. Sanji: Not bad, but it is a bit boring. The black and white is not terribly interesting. I bet there are some really kick-butt pictures of this fellow that you could use instead! 7/10.

Avenir: Good image quality! The colors are crisp. My only problem is that the subject is not involved enough. Other than that, it's a good one. 8/10.

---

I've finally changed my avatar! I decided to keep going with the Harlock thing, but I took it in a bit of a different direction. This is the Harlock puchuu from episode 22 of Excel Saga! You can even see Excel acting silly in the lower left corner.

Mistress-Samwise:

It has pretty good quality. Everything is sharp, and there's no noticeable grain. However, the color palette is very dull. Nothing is really vibrant, and the avatar suffers because of it. Nothing jumps out, so it is not very noticeable. Vibrant colors are always something nice to have in an avatar.

I like how the border blends in with the rest of the image, though.

Rating: 8.2/10

well, there was this problem, the site wouldn't let me put anything larger, saying that it exceeded the size, so that was a smaller pic that i thought would work, i'll try working with a larger one.

[Captain Maw, Please try to leave a rating when posting here, even if its in response to another post. Either edit in a rating for the person above this post, or try to remember this next time. ~R.Smith]

7.5/10

The picture is to small. The avatar just isn't good really at all. But I love AQTHF so much I gave your avatar a few extra points

Chaoz- Um I give you a 8.5/10
I don't really like it for some odd reason...

Ebie: It's a little grainy, and I don't really like the size. 7/10

Holy crud.
com_bun_bun:
If its cuteness your going for...major miss. That avatar looks like a police, white rabbit version of Frank (Donnie Darko anyone?). Its oddily frightening. its so scary, Im giving you a 9.9/10.
Why?
Clear image.
Nice effect.
Creepy(always a plus).
Menacingly pink(normally I would subtract for this..but it works today.)

lates.

BigOZ:
Thumbs up: It's Roger, always a plus. He's cute.
Thumbs Down: The contrast is very low. It's an odd size. Any way you could have more of him?

8.5/10

Okay, I think I'm finally happy with this one. What do you think?

Um...

Um.... um.... um....

10, of course! Love that picture of Hughes!

BabyGhia

Awww wow Baby Ghia I love that one of Vash! Such a excellent pose and The Manga style rules! Clear and crisp! 10 !! ^_^""

-Beth McBeth

BethMcBeth:

Well, I assume that this is one of your own drawings, so I'll critique that also.

First of all, the quality is fine. The hair looks a bit grainy, but overall it's OK.

However, Dorothy looks like a vampire about to bite someone's neck. Kind of out of character for Dorothy, as I doubt she could become a vampire (seeing as it would be difficult to actually bite her neck).

Might be cool around Halloween, but not around April Fool's Day.

7.6/10

EDIT: And, uh, Happy April Fool's?

You've desecrated Sean Connery! @_@ x_X SHINEH!!!!!!!!!!!! 8/10

Evan, classic AS April Fool's joke. 10/10

Current April Fool's avatar: