Rate the Avatar

quote:

I can't even tell what the image is R.Dorothied. However teh b/w effect is well done and the picture is clear and defined. Even though I have no idea what it is supposed to be.

Psssh, it's me. Being THUGXCORE.

BIGOZ- I love yours. 101010101010/10.



CUZ LIEK, I'M LIEK, AN ESKIMO!

you look silly in a good way 8/10

R_Dorothied: Funny picture, but it's pretty blurry. 5/10

Next person, please rate my avatar and Evan's.

Umino,
Quality of image is very good. The clarity is very well done, and there is no sight of grain at all. This could very well be your best avatar (that I have seen thus far) yet. Overall, nice job. I give it a 9/10

evanASF27,
Quality of image is pretty good. The clarity is good, and there is little grain in the image. I like how you blended both images together to become one. It works well in this case. Overall, good job. I give it a 8.5/10

R_Dorothied,
Quality of image is good. It may be a little too blurry, but I like the grayscale effect. I do not notice any grain in the picture, either. Overall, it's pretty good. I give it a 8/10

BigOZ,
Quality of image is good. There isn't any grain in the avatar, but the background is kind of plain. Other than that, it's a pretty good avatar you got there. I give it a 8/10

Avenir,
Quality of image is good. There is little grain that is hard to notice, but the clarity is good for the most part. It's a pretty nice avatar. I give it a 8.5/10

Wingnut,
Quality of image is pretty good. There is some grain, but nothing too noticable. The background works well with the main object. Overall, it's a pretty good avatar. I give it a 8/10

Later,
Trisa

I think I may have rated this, not sure. Like your other avatars, this one is nice and clean. No grain, and it fits with the 'Sister Princess' theme you've had lately. 10/10

Umino: Let's see...Cutie Honey, huh?

Pros:
1) Nice clear image.
2) No sign of grain.
3) Good colors, nicely done.
4) Good border.

Cons:
1) Kinda close up. But still good. No point taken.

Overall: 10/10

Later days:
JA

Edit: No one knows who my avatar is. It's Slayn Wilder from Growlanser III. (I made this myself. I'm so proud. )

Edit2: Here's another I want you to rate. Rate both my Slayn and my Raimy avatar.

• Attachment: raimyavborder.bmp

Juvenile Angel-

The avatar your using- nice color, a tiny bit blury but not so that it's distracting. The border's interesting but it's just a straight on look at the character. There's no life or personality in it 4/10

The avatar you've linked- very cute, same problem with bluryness but the angle's more interesting, there a lot more life in it. The border works much better on this one. On the one your using it seems almost as an afterthought, but it adds something to this one. I think it would be a very good avatar for you 8/10
-------------------------

My avatar's Dorothy ^_^ I love drawing her with orange hair.


muchlove
-Dork

Dork: It's a little pixely and only like 6 colors, but I like the style. 8/10.

It's a nice avatar, but it's a little too grainy for my tastes. 7/10

Umino, your Avatar is spectacular. I don't know how you got such great quality out of a .gif image (rather than a .png). Colorful, clear, and very fitting. Plus, an angle of view which is a variation from the norm.

I don't know what it is, but there's just something about it that's preventing from me giving it a perfect 10. Still, it's great.

9.9/10

Seeing as I have reviewed Wienberg's avatar many times prior, I will instead take this time to review Umino's.

Umino - 9 out of 10

My goodness, this is a spectacular avatar; perhaps your best thus far. The bright and lucious colors make the image shine. However, there is some visible but minor pixelation. In conclusion, a fantastic avatar.

EDIT: Umino, if it remedies anything, I altered your avatar to PNG format if you would like it.

Avenir: It's a nice avatar and very dark. But I can barely tell what it is (in terms of what the pictures of, it has nothing to do with quality). I'm going to guess it's a helicopter, since its just a shadow-like thing. It's a little grainy, but not so much that it's really noticable. It's a nice avatar overall, though.

Overall: 8.78/10

Later days:
JA

Juvenile Angel 10/10

Avenir 10/10

It's kinda funny, and not too grainy. 7/10

EDIT:

Thank you, Avenir but I'll just stick with the one I have. Thanks anyway.

Seeing as I have already reviewed Umino's avatar, I shall review R. Jesse's.

R. Jesse - 6 out of 10

I'm unsure of what to make of it; it's quite obscure for an avatar, which I speak positively. Unfortunately, the use of two "Anti-Goat" phrases is rather redundant and I'm not very fond of the odd image margins and the enhanced borderline at the top. However, it is rather different.

JA:
Your avatar is spectacular. No noticible grain, if any. Nice color, well blended. Honestly, its a perfect avatar. The song/poem/whatever quote is good too.

Score:PERFECT 10/10

Well, I will say that one does not see many manga images around, so I suppose that is a plus in your favor. Otherwise, there is noticeable grain in the image: that hurts its quality quite a lot. Though I like horizontal avatars (I use them myself from time to time), I do not think they are nearly as effective at the smaller dimensions.

Ultimately, not a terrible avatar: the biggest problem is most definitely the grain, followed by the dimensions (I really do not think they work out so well at that size).

Clarity: 6.8 / 10.0
Originality: 8.0 / 10.0
Color: 7.0 / 10.0
Stature: 7.2 / 10.0

Objective: 7.33 / 10.00
Opinion: 6.50 / 10.00

Overall: 7.12 / 10.00

Fallen Pheonix:

You have a really clear avatar. The emotion of the character on it suits your title well. However, I do think that border needs to be chucked. 7/10.

The Fallen Phoenix - 9 out of 10

A very stunning avatar if I ever laid eyes on one. While I won't word assumptions as to where it might be captured from, I adore the radiant colors thoughout the image, which the enhanced dimensions justify greatly. However, there is noticeable pixelization in some areas that grain the image; this is a minority. A very nice avatar overall with a solid nine of ten rating.

I really can't tell what your avatar is, but logically it's the helicopter-looking machine in your signature. It looks like it's part of a movie, or a 3D model. Either way it's very well done, although a bit of clarifying on the helicopter\ship\transport in your avatar would make it look even better.

8.8\10